As of now, the list has already been decided upon through 2018, with the only requirement being to cut down upon the honorable mentions listed: >/2018/ Call of Duty: Black Ops III Ion Fury Kingdom Come: Deliverance Spyro Reignited Trilogy World War 3 <[Honorable mentions] Dusk Hades Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom Overload Return of the Obra Dinn The Messenger Warhammer 40,000: Mechanicus >/2017/ A Hat in Time Cuphead Hollow Knight Sonic Mania South Park: The Fractured But Whole <[Honorable mentions] Alien Shooter TD Battle Brothers Black: The Fall Clone Hero Gun-Running War Dogs Prey Ruiner Spark the Electric Jester The Mummy Demastered Thimbleweed Park >/2016/ Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare Factorio Stardew Valley Superhot Titanfall 2 <[Honorable Mentions] Blue Revolver Darkest Dungeon Deadbolt Far Cry Primal Mother Russia Bleeds Redout Shadow of the Beast Shantae: 1/2 Genie Hero XCOM >/2015/ Call of Duty: Black Ops III Crypt of the Necrodancer Fast Racing NEO Hotline Miami 2 Rocket League <[Honorable mentions] Axoim Verge Downwell Fallout 4 Just Cause 3 Ori and the Blind Forest Pixel Heroes Skyhill >/2014/ Alien: Isolation Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor South Park: The Stick of Truth The Talos Principle Wasteland 2 <[Honorable mentions] Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Child of Light Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze Freedom Planet Gaunlet Men of War Assault Squad 2 Mercenary Kings Shovel Knight Strider Subnautica Sunset Overdrive The Crew Titanfall Toybox Turbos TxK Watch_Dogs >/2013/ Battleblock Theater Dead Rising 3 Grand Theft Auto V Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon Rayman Legends <[Honorable mentions] Bernd and the Mystery of Unteralterbach Batman: Arkham Origins Call of Duty: Ghosts Crysis 3 Don't Starve Guacamelee! Iron Man 3: The Official Game Monaco: What's Yours Is Mine Marlow Briggs and the Mask of Death Outlast Papers, Please Payday 2 Rise of the Triad Risk of Rain Shadow Warrior Shadowrun Returns The Amazing Spider-Man The Bureau: XCOM Declassified The Stanley Parable >/2012/ Call of Duty: Black Ops II Dust: An Elysian Tail Hotline Miami Max Payne 3 The Darkness II <[Honorable mentions] Darksiders II Dishonored Dustforce Far Cry 3 Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams Halo 4 Katawa Shoujo Legend of Grimrock Mark Of The Ninja Need for Speed: Most Wanted SCP: Containment Breach Scribblenauts Unlimited Sine Mora Sleeping Dogs Spec Ops: The Line ZombiU >/2011/ Dead Rising 2: Off the Record Deus Ex: Human Revolution Mortal Kombat Rayman Origins Serious Sam 3: BFE <[Honorable mentions] Alice: Madness Returns Call of Duty: MW3 Dead Island F.3.A.R. Kerbal Space Program Payday: The Heist Terraria Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine >/2010/ Bioshock 2 Darksiders Donkey Kong Country Returns Fallout: New Vegas Halo: Reach <[Honorable mentions] Alpha Protocol Amnesia: The Dark Descent Back to the Future: The Game Call of Duty: Black Ops Castlevania: Lords of Shadow Dead Rising 2 Epic Mickey Limbo Metro 2033 Red Steel 2 Scott Pilgrim vs. The World: The Game Shantae: Risky's Revenge Sid Meier's Civilization V Split/Second Super Meat Boy >/2009/ Batman: Arkham Asylum Halo Wars Left 4 Dead 2 Prototype Punch-Out!! <[Honorable Mentions] Brutal Legend Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood Cursed Mountain Ghostbusters Killing Floor Minecraft Classic Overlord 2 X-Men Origins: Wolverine - Uncaged Edition Zombie Shooter 2 >/2008/ Audiosurf Dead Space Iron Man Spelunky Saints Row 2 <[Honorable Mentions] Call of Duty: World At War Castle Crashers Fallout 3 Frontlines: Fuel of War Grand Theft Auto IV Left 4 Dead Nanostray 2 Pure >/2007/ Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Crysis Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl The Orange Box <[Honorable Mentions] BioShock Colin McRae: Dirt Dementium: The Ward Enemy Territory: Quake Wars Mario Strikers Charged Overlord The Witcher Tomb Raider: Anniversary World in Conflict >/2006/ Bully Hitman: Blood Money Marvel: Ultimate Alliance Prey Tomb Raider: Legend <[Honorable Mentions] Black Dark Messiah of Might and Magic F.E.A.R.: Extraction Point Guitar Hero II Gun Half-Life 2: Episode 1 Medieval II: Total War Slaves to Armok: God of Blood - Chapter II: Dwarf Fortress Titan Quest Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six: Vegas TrackMania Nations >/2005/ Battlefield 2 Burnout Revenge F.E.A.R. SWAT 4 Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory <[Honorable Mentions] Batman Begins God of War Need for Speed: Most Wanted Obscure Psychonauts Sid Meier's Civilization IV Super Mario Strikers The Matrix: Path of Neo TimeSitters: Future Perfect Worms 4 Mayhem >/2004/ Half Life 2 Halo 2 Grand Theft Auto San Andreas Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates <[Honorable Mentions] Burnout 3 Takedown Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay Crash Twinsanity Far Cry Manhunt Metroid Prime 2 Need For Speed Underground 2 Painkiller Second Sight Star Wars: Battlefront The Sims 2 The Suffering Unreal Tournament 2004 Van Helsing Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War >/2003/ Call of Duty Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX3 Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic <[Honorable Mentions] Beyond Good & Evil Jak II Postal 2 Rayman 3 The Simpsons: Hit & Run Tron 2.0 XIII >/2002/ Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Metroid Prime Sly Cooper & The Theivius Raccoonus The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind <[Honorable Mentions] Battlefield 1942 BloodRayne Grand Theft Auto Vice City LEGO Island Xtreme Stunts MechAssault Pac-Man World 2 Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Star Wars Jedi Knight 2 Jedi Outcast Tetris Worlds (GC/Xbox) Timesplitters 2 >/2001/ Burnout Halo Max Payne Serious Sam Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II - Rogue Leader <[Honorable Mentions] Arcanum Conker's Bad Fur Day Empire Earth LEGO Island 2: The Brickster's Revenge GTA3 Gothic IL2 Oni SSX Tricky Zoo Tycoon >/2000/ American McGee's Alice Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Deus Ex Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine Tony Hawk 2 <[Honorable Mentions] Banjo Tooie Baldur's Gate 2 Metropolis Street Racer Perfect Dark Spider-Man Star Trek: Voyager - Elite Force >/1999/ Age of Empires II Rayman 2 Star Wars Episode I Racer Unreal Tournament Worms Armageddon <[Honorable Mentions] Dungeon Keeper 2 Lego Racers RollerCoaster Tycoon Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Quake III >/1998/ Apocalypse Spyro the Dragon StarCraft I Thief: The Dark Project Turok 2 <[Honorable Mentions] Baldur's Gate Fallout 2 Grim Fandango Half-Life Might and Magic VI: The Mandate of Heaven >/1997/ Blood Crash Bandicoot 2 Fallout Goldeneye 007 Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <[Honorable Mentions] Dungeon Keeper Shadow Warrior Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire Tetrisphere >/1996/ Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Civilization II Duke Nukem Quake Tomb Raider <[Honorable Mentions] Crash Bandicoot Descent II Diablo Killer Instinct 2 Master of Orion II: Battle at Antares The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Twisted Metal 2 >/1995/ Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn Donkey Kong Country 2 Full Throttle MechWarrior 2 Twisted Metal <[Honorable Mentions] Albion Descent Earthworm Jim 2 I Have No Mouth Phantasmagoria Prehistorik Man Rayman WarCraft II >/1994/ Doom II Earthworm Jim Mega Turrican System Shock X-COM: UFO Unknown <[Honorable Mentions] Donkey Kong Country Jazz Jackrabbit Killer Instinct NBA Jam The Incredible Machine 2 Uniracers >/1993/ Cannon Fodder Doom SimCity 2000 Star Fox The Terminator (SEGA CD) <[Honorable Mentions] Betrayal at Krondor Day of the Tentacle Frontier: Elite II Might and Magic V: Darkside of Xeen Plok Prince of Persia 2 Star Wars: X-Wing The Chaos Engine The I

>>608676 '93 and '92 keep getting cut off for some reason, so here's a repost of those two years >/1993/ Cannon Fodder Doom SimCity 2000 Star Fox The Terminator (SEGA CD) <[Honorable Mentions] Betrayal at Krondor Day of the Tentacle Frontier: Elite II Might and Magic V: Darkside of Xeen Plok Prince of Persia 2 Star Wars: X-Wing The Chaos Engine The Incredible Machine The Lost Vikings >/1992/ Alone in the Dark Flashback Super Star Wars Ultima VII Wolfenstein 3D <[Honorable Mentions] Darklands King's Quest VI: Heir Today, Gone Tomorrow Might and Magic IV: Clouds of Xeen

Another Anon is covering 2019 afterwards, himself, since it seems like very Anons want to contribute from that point onward and he's the only one that has played anything for those years. If you want to dispute any of the game listed as the best for any particular year, then actually post about the game that you want to remove, and which of the honorable mentions you think it should be replace by. If other Anons concur, then we'll change the game listed. As far as adding any new games, they'll only be considered for honorable mentions unless several another Anons can concur that the game is just "that good" to be worth replacing what's already listed

>>608676 Here is a new list, which has been more or less finalized. Top game is GOTY, bottom 3 are Honorable Mentions. See pic related for reference how the chart will most likely look. Here is the list 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Unknown Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Jazz Jackrabbit <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <SiN <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Rollercoaster Tycoon <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Grand Theft Auto III* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Halo: Combat Evolved Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Red Faction <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Beyond Good & Evil 2004: >Halo 2* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Dishonored <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Crypt of the Necrodancer <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Dishonored 2 <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Call of Duty: Black Ops 4 <Ion Fury 2019: >Disco Elysium* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Risk of Rain 2 Boneworks <Warsaw <Luigi's Mansion 3 <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Among Us* Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Hades Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Deathloop* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Valheim Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks Feel free to suggest any of the games seen here, but keep in mind not all of them will make it due to the 8 game limit. This list is planned to be finished up by the end of the week, and actually drawn up shortly after, to be frank, this list will likely take weeks, and either look similar, or worse than this one. I have gotten good feedback, and most already agree with what's on this list, but feel free to give me your input.

>>608679 >Here is a new list No, it is not, FUCK OFF!

>>608679 For the sake of finishing this list quickly, and to avoid any undue autism, right now I'm thinking that any changes people want to see will be done to Honorable mentions(red text). If you want to replace any other games, you will have to give a good reason(and a good game). Other than that, I'm hoping it will be finalized by the end of the weekend

>>608682 >For the sake of finishing this list quickly, and to avoid any undue autism YOU ARE REMOVING GAMES THAT PEOPLE ALREADY DECIDED UPON, YOU CAN DO WHATEVER YOU WANT FOR 2019 ONWARD SINCE NO ONE WANT'S TO POST ANYTHING FOR THOSE YEARS, BUT YOU ARE NOT TOUCH 2018 AND BEFORE!

The two lists are very similar(with mine cutting all but 8 games out of them), but there are some differences, see >>608585 for reference This does not account for some other games in the "Honorable Mentions List" seen in >>608676 So if you want to suggest anything from there, I suggest you do so now. I do think that most of the games here are already about as iconic as they get, with many missing from that other list altogether

Doing this by year is fucking stupid, just do it by genre and don't put arbitrary limits on the number of games.

>>608684 >The two lists are very similar No, they're not. >with mine cutting all but 8 games out of them You're doing more changes than that. >So if you want to suggest anything from there That ENTIRE list. you can discussion the honorable mentions, but you are NOT touching the "best" that were already decided upon.

>>608686 >just do it by genre and don't put arbitrary limits on the number of games It's done by year and numbers for the purpose of provided a quick and dirty guide to get them started. Another Anon who's developing the actual design, displayed listed genre with the games in question, so that should help.

>>608685 No offense, but you have something like "Bern and the mystery of Unteralterbach" on your list, but missed out on some of the classics like Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis or Carmaggedon. Plus, your suggestions were awful dogshit for each year, which shows me you know nothing about gaming. I have no vendetta, but my list will get finished quicker, and most of the titles on that list already came from yours. You're sperging the fuck out right now, which also shows that you're not capable of managing this list >>608686 I do agree with you, but this was the stipulation that OP put, so I chose to respect his wishes. If I was him, I would also reach out to some of the gaming forums, like NMA or RPG Codex for example, to ask them the same question and see if they could point to some more obscure titles to go on the list, ones we may not even know about. Obviously, this wouldn't just go for RPG games, RTS and Adventure games also have dedicated communities similar to them. Please see >>608679 and tell me what you think

>>608691 >but you have something like "Bern and the mystery of Unteralterbach" on your list That what Anon's contended for the list. >but missed out on some of the classics like Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis or Carmaggedon Other Anons decided that there were other games that were over better quality than those titles. >Plus, your suggestions were awful dogshit for each year, which shows me you know nothing about gaming. The suggestions were based off of what people had actually played. >I have no vendetta Yes, you do. You make 8000 character rants to justify why every subsequent Call of Duty is the "best" game released in each of it's respective years. You defending literal baizuo propaganda like Disco Elysium and the Outer Worlds. And, you swapped out huge swaths of the list despite several Anons having already gone over the respective years and voicing what they think should be listed. >and most of the titles on that list already came from yours And, you're changing the games that you don't "like" despite other Anons wanting those games there. >You're sperging the fuck out right now I'm angry because you're replacing other people's opinions, opinions they made as a collective group, with your own singular opinion and demanding that everyone ignore that. >I would also reach out to some of the gaming forums, like NMA or RPG Codex for example Why not ask Cuckchan while we're add it?!

>>608679 Why the fuck is trash like Call of Duty on here at all? >>608691 Unteralterbach is great.

>>608694 >Why the fuck is trash like Call of Duty on here at all? Everything since 2009 is solely because of [2418f4]'s recommendation that every Call of Duty is the best game of it's respective year. If you want to see the lengths he goes to in order to defend it, see: https://archive.ph/js5gA#599722

>>608695 >every Call of Duty is the best game of it's respective year. Where the fuck did this person even come from?

>>608694 Many of the games suggested for later years were lacking, and I explained why I think COD games have a spot on this list in the previous thread, for example >>608655 >>608647 Of course, you are free to suggest other games over them, but it will have to be a good game, as the reasoning for it's removal has to be something else than "It's COD". I have hundreds of hours in these games, so I know that these games have more to offer than those who haven't played them, or don't know anything about them I should mention I am trying to be an impartial party, I have removed many of my initial suggestions, including other COD games, for those that other anons wanted already. There are three COD games on "Honorable Mentions" list(2014, 2018 and 2020), so if you don't want to see them, you can start by suggesting better games take their place, or at least games you think are better in your eyes >>608696 GOTY are the ones in green text, and only one COD game is "best for that year"(COD 4, which people universally agree deserves that spot)

>>608697 You need to develop some taste, you fucking retard.

>including any Call of Duty at all >including any FPS at all I just got there and what the hell are you doing that one anon. Get that trash out. Now with that said, are we doing best games or recommendations?

>>608699 Please read the list >>608679 I assure you I have better taste, and more knowledge on gaming in general, than OP. I should also not that the last thread didn't have anyone contributing past 2016, which shows that many people here don't even play whatever games they're suggesting

>>608701 If you want any of these games gone, I suggest you give me some replacements. Start with 2014, 2018 and 2020, see the red text in >>608679 for honorable mentions, which are now being edited

>>608703 >I should also not that the last thread didn't have anyone contributing past 2016 I motion that we simply write "no good games this year" for every year after 201something. It's true too.

>>608705 That is false, as my list already demonstrated. If you have no actual games to suggest, good for you, I hope people who actually do play them will, to round out the list. The old list will take months to finish, with the way OP is posting, and will likely have meme trash on it nobody will take seriously. My list filters that

>>608703 >I assure you I have better taste, and more knowledge on gaming in general, than OP. I don't think it's actually possible to have worse taste than you. Someone recommending Candy Crush for GOTYAY would have better taste than you. Literally LMFAO. >>608704 >If you want any of these games gone Remove CODshit, for starters. >>608705 Hollow Knight was 2017 and I thought it was pretty decent. Risk of Rain 2 was also pretty good and that was 2019.

>>608697 >I explained why I think COD games have a spot on this list No one is denying that some of the CoD games are good. However, everyone else disputes everything after W@W is of any actual quality, and only added some of the games to placate you. I now see that was a mistake. >>608699 I get the feeling he's a rapefugee from Cuckchan. >>608701 >including any FPS at all You denying the supremacy of games like F.E.A.R., Metroid Prime, Serious Sam, and Quake? >>608703 >Please read the list We have, that's the reason why I even caught any of what you were doing in the first place. >I assure you I have better taste <Proceeds to recommend TLoU, RDR2, and Disco Elysium >and more knowledge on gaming in general, than OP I never claimed to know "everything", that's why I referred to the opinions of other Anons. An action you are clearly disregarding. >>608706 >That is false, as my list already demonstrated. Considering the changes you have made, the Torpedo might actually be right for once.

>>608707 >Remove CODshit for starters Do you have any actual suggestions for the replacements? Let's see your taste, then.

>>608709 Literally just remove CODshit and the list is more or less fine.

>>608710 If you have no games to recommend, why should I take anything you're saying seriously? I should stress anons already gave me good recommendations for the list already. If you have none, why are you even here?

>>608709 >>608710 How does this look: >/2018/ <Call of Duty: Black Ops III Replaced by Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom >/2016/ <Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare Replace by Shadow of the Beast >/2015/ <Call of Duty: Black Ops III Replaced by ''Downwell' >/2012/ <Call of Duty: Black Ops II Replaced by Darksiders II

>>608676 >/2018/ >Call of Duty: Black Ops III >/2015/ >Call of Duty: Black Ops III

>>608713 A typo. That was BLOPS4.

>>608711 You like CODshit, why should I take anything you say seriously? >>608712 Any list without CODshit is better than a list with CODshit.

>>608708 >You denying the supremacy of games like F.E.A.R., Metroid Prime, Serious Sam, and Quake? I'm bad at shooting things anyway, so I won't argue. So I looked up, and Pathfinder: Kingmaker is 2018. How about that?

>>608717 >So I looked up, and Pathfinder: Kingmaker is 2018. How about that? Did you play it? Also can [febb61] also concur that it's a good game.

>>608712 >2018 I would prefer actual good videogames to suggested. Some indie 2D Platformer for the switch I never heard of seems like a suggestion only made out of spite >2016 What I'm seeing isn't really winning me over. Again, seem like desperate last minute suggestions >2015 Another indie game, this time in pixel flavor. No >2012 This one actually looks like a competent video game. I would be open to putting that up for one of the honorable mentions Again, please suggest video games people actually know about, or at least ones that are good. Suggesting about a dozen shitty indie games people only put because they played them is the reason why there are two lists, and the other has dozens of titles on it, which I doubt more than one person here played, in some instances. Again, if you actually want one of these COD games gone, feel free to suggest me something, starting with Honorable Mentions(2014/2018/2020)

>>608720 Again, please acquire some taste.

>>608718 I could put Pathfinder: Kingmaker in Honorable Mentions in 2018. I assume it would replace BLOPS 4, in this case? Does anyone disagree? See anon, I knew you could suggest at least 1 good video game. Does anyone have any other games? Preferably, not indie pixel games, unless other people actually played them

>>608722 >Preferably, not indie pixel games Better than COD.

>>608720 >Some indie 2D Platformer for the switch I never heard <The remake of a Sega classic is now an "Indie 2D Platformer" And, you were calling me "uninformed"? >What I'm seeing isn't really winning me over. <The remake of a Sony classic into an awesome 2.5d character action game

>>608725 I've heard of Wonder boy, obviously. I wasn't aware it was remade, because I don't follow nintendo consoles. I play real video games

>>608727 >because I don't follow nintendo consoles >I play real video games I was wrong, you're not from Cuckchan, YOU'RE FROM FUCKING GAMEFAQS!

>>608727 >because I don't follow nintendo consoles. I play real video games Nobody tell cakekike, he'll throw a fit.

List as it stands now 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Unknown Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Jazz Jackrabbit <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <SiN <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Rollercoaster Tycoon <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Grand Theft Auto III* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Halo: Combat Evolved Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Red Faction <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Beyond Good & Evil 2004: >Halo 2* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Dishonored <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Crypt of the Necrodancer <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Dishonored 2 <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Disco Elysium* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Risk of Rain 2 Boneworks <Warsaw <Luigi's Mansion 3 <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Among Us* Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Hades Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Deathloop* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Valheim Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks Games in redtext are "honorable mentions". If you have any games you would like to suggest to replace them, suggest them. There are a whole bunch people suggested already here >>608676

I forgot to mention that one anon brought this up in the last thread: Which GTA should be the GOTY, GTA 3 or GTA San Andreas? GTA 3 is the current GOTY, and that means Halo 2 is the GOTY for that year, but if San Andreas was GOTY, then Halo: Combat Evolved would be the current GOTY in that case for 2001

>>608730 >List as it stands now You are not making this list. You are too immature, you fail to be objective, and you're dictating it without the opinions other Anons have expressed.

>>608732 >You are too immature I'll bet my left nut he's underage.

>>608733 I think he's legitimately autistic, I'm not saying that as an insult.

So, here is the "final" list for the "best" of the years 1992-2018: >/2018/ Ion Fury Kingdom Come: Deliverance Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom Spyro Reignited Trilogy World War 3 >/2017/ A Hat in Time Cuphead Hollow Knight Sonic Mania South Park: The Fractured But Whole >/2016/ Factorio Shadow of the Beast Stardew Valley Superhot Titanfall 2 >/2015/ Crypt of the Necrodancer Downwell Fast Racing NEO Hotline Miami 2 Rocket League >/2014/ Alien: Isolation Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor South Park: The Stick of Truth The Talos Principle Wasteland 2 >/2013/ Battleblock Theater Dead Rising 3 Grand Theft Auto V Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon Rayman Legends >/2012/ Darksiders II Dust: An Elysian Tail Hotline Miami Max Payne 3 The Darkness II >/2011/ Dead Rising 2: Off the Record Deus Ex: Human Revolution Mortal Kombat Rayman Origins Serious Sam 3: BFE >/2010/ Bioshock 2 Darksiders Donkey Kong Country Returns Fallout: New Vegas Halo: Reach >/2009/ Batman: Arkham Asylum Halo Wars Left 4 Dead 2 Prototype Punch-Out!! >/2008/ Audiosurf Dead Space Iron Man Spelunky Saints Row 2 >/2007/ Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Crysis Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl The Orange Box >/2006/ Bully Hitman: Blood Money Marvel: Ultimate Alliance Prey Tomb Raider: Legend >/2005/ Battlefield 2 Burnout Revenge F.E.A.R. SWAT 4 Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory >/2004/ Half Life 2 Halo 2 Grand Theft Auto San Andreas Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates >/2003/ Call of Duty Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX3 Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic >/2002/ Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Metroid Prime Sly Cooper & The Theivius Raccoonus The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind >/2001/ Burnout Halo Max Payne Serious Sam Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II - Rogue Leader >/2000/ American McGee's Alice Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Deus Ex Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine Tony Hawk 2 >/1999/ Age of Empires II Rayman 2 Star Wars Episode I Racer Unreal Tournament Worms Armageddon >/1998/ Apocalypse Spyro the Dragon StarCraft I Thief: The Dark Project Turok 2 >/1997/ Blood Crash Bandicoot 2 Fallout Goldeneye 007 Turok: Dinosaur Hunter >/1996/ Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Civilization II Duke Nukem Quake Tomb Raider >/1995/ Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn Donkey Kong Country 2 Full Throttle MechWarrior 2 Twisted Metal >/1994/ Doom II Earthworm Jim Mega Turrican System Shock X-COM: UFO Unknown >/1993/ Cannon Fodder Doom SimCity 2000 Star Fox The Terminator (SEGA CD) >/1992/ Alone in the Dark Flashback Super Star Wars Ultima VII Wolfenstein 3D As I said prior, the autist can have free reign for 2019-2021 since no one seems to care about three years.

And, now to shorten the list of honorable mentions of those years, here's currently what we have listed: <[2018 Honorable mentions] Call of Duty: Black Ops IIII Dusk Hades Overload Return of the Obra Dinn The Messenger Warhammer 40,000: Mechanicus <[2017 Honorable mentions] Alien Shooter TD Battle Brothers Black: The Fall Clone Hero Gun-Running War Dogs Prey Ruiner Spark the Electric Jester The Mummy Demastered Thimbleweed Park <[2016 Honorable Mentions] Blue Revolver Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Deadbolt Far Cry Primal Mother Russia Bleeds Redout Shantae: 1/2 Genie Hero XCOM <[2015 Honorable mentions] Axoim Verge Call of Duty: Black Ops III Fallout 4 Just Cause 3 Ori and the Blind Forest Pixel Heroes Skyhill <[2014 Honorable mentions] Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Child of Light Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze Freedom Planet Gaunlet Men of War Assault Squad 2 Mercenary Kings Shovel Knight Strider Subnautica Sunset Overdrive The Crew Titanfall Toybox Turbos TxK Watch_Dogs <[2013 Honorable mentions] Bernd and the Mystery of Unteralterbach Batman: Arkham Origins Call of Duty: Ghosts Crysis 3 Don't Starve Guacamelee! Iron Man 3: The Official Game Monaco: What's Yours Is Mine Marlow Briggs and the Mask of Death Outlast Papers, Please Payday 2 Rise of the Triad Risk of Rain Shadow Warrior Shadowrun Returns The Amazing Spider-Man The Bureau: XCOM Declassified The Stanley Parable <[2012 Honorable mentions] Call of Duty: Black Ops II Dishonored Dustforce Far Cry 3 Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams Halo 4 Katawa Shoujo Legend of Grimrock Mark Of The Ninja Need for Speed: Most Wanted SCP: Containment Breach Scribblenauts Unlimited Sine Mora Sleeping Dogs Spec Ops: The Line ZombiU <[2011 Honorable mentions] Alice: Madness Returns Call of Duty: MW3 Dead Island F.3.A.R. Kerbal Space Program Payday: The Heist Terraria Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine <[2010 Honorable mentions] Alpha Protocol Amnesia: The Dark Descent Back to the Future: The Game Call of Duty: Black Ops Castlevania: Lords of Shadow Dead Rising 2 Epic Mickey Limbo Metro 2033 Red Steel 2 Scott Pilgrim vs. The World: The Game Shantae: Risky's Revenge Sid Meier's Civilization V Split/Second Super Meat Boy <[2009 Honorable Mentions] Brutal Legend Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood Cursed Mountain Ghostbusters Killing Floor Minecraft Classic Overlord 2 X-Men Origins: Wolverine - Uncaged Edition Zombie Shooter 2 <[2008 Honorable Mentions] Call of Duty: World At War Castle Crashers Fallout 3 Frontlines: Fuel of War Grand Theft Auto IV Left 4 Dead Nanostray 2 Pure <[2007 Honorable Mentions] BioShock Colin McRae: Dirt Dementium: The Ward Enemy Territory: Quake Wars Mario Strikers Charged Overlord The Witcher Tomb Raider: Anniversary World in Conflict <[2006 Honorable Mentions] Black Dark Messiah of Might and Magic F.E.A.R.: Extraction Point Guitar Hero II Gun Half-Life 2: Episode 1 Medieval II: Total War Slaves to Armok: God of Blood - Chapter II: Dwarf Fortress Titan Quest Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six: Vegas TrackMania Nations <[2005 Honorable Mentions] Batman Begins God of War Need for Speed: Most Wanted Obscure Psychonauts Sid Meier's Civilization IV Super Mario Strikers The Matrix: Path of Neo TimeSitters: Future Perfect Worms 4 Mayhem <[2004 Honorable Mentions] Burnout 3 Takedown Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay Crash Twinsanity Far Cry Manhunt Metroid Prime 2 Need For Speed Underground 2 Painkiller Second Sight Star Wars: Battlefront The Sims 2 The Suffering Unreal Tournament 2004 Van Helsing Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War <[2003 Honorable Mentions] Beyond Good & Evil Jak II Postal 2 Rayman 3 The Simpsons: Hit & Run Tron 2.0 XIII <[2002 Honorable Mentions] Battlefield 1942 BloodRayne Grand Theft Auto Vice City LEGO Island Xtreme Stunts MechAssault Pac-Man World 2 Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Star Wars Jedi Knight 2 Jedi Outcast Tetris Worlds (GC/Xbox) Timesplitters 2 <[2001 Honorable Mentions] Arcanum Conker's Bad Fur Day Empire Earth LEGO Island 2: The Brickster's Revenge GTA3 Gothic IL2 Oni SSX Tricky Zoo Tycoon <[2000 Honorable Mentions] Banjo Tooie Baldur's Gate 2 Metropolis Street Racer Perfect Dark Spider-Man Star Trek: Voyager - Elite Force <[1999 Honorable Mentions] Dungeon Keeper 2 Lego Racers RollerCoaster Tycoon Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Quake III <[1998 Honorable Mentions] Baldur's Gate Fallout 2 Grim Fandango Half-Life Might and Magic VI: The Mandate of Heaven <[1997 Honorable Mentions] Dungeon Keeper Shadow Warrior Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire Tetrisphere <[1996 Honorable Mentions] Crash Bandicoot Descent II Diablo Killer Instinct 2 Master of Orion II: Battle at Antares The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Twisted Metal 2 <[1995 Honorable Mentions] Albion Descent Earthworm Jim 2 I Have No Mouth Phantasmagoria Prehistorik Man Rayman WarCraft II <[1994 Honorable Mentions] Donkey Kong Country Jazz Jackrabbit Killer Instinct NBA Jam The Incredible Machine 2 Uniracers <[1993 Honorable Mentions] Betrayal at Krondor Day of the Tentacle Frontier: Elite II Might and Magic V: Darkside of Xeen Plok Prince of Persia 2 Star Wars: X-Wing The Chaos Engine The Incredible Machine The Lost Vikings <[1992 Honorable Mentions] Darklands King's Quest VI: Heir Today, Gone Tomorrow Might and Magic IV: Clouds of Xeen

>>608737 I gave a recommendation for 2019. >>608707

>>608726 >Monster boy and the cursed kingdom <A Sega Classic ? >Shadow Of The Beast <A Remake of a Sony Classic <A Sony Classic ?? >Darksiders II I don't really like it, i still prefer the first, but it's a solid Game at least, so i wouldn't sperg about it, and the japs need more games like that instead of the same trash they play >>608737 For 2011, i'll like some Rainbow Six instead of Sam, because of some things about the 3rd Game that are shitty as fuck, but that's some personal opinions, and i'll respect if the anons thinks that it'll deserve the spot. Overall, i think it's a good list and fuck everyone who fucking whines about it but don't Help.building it because they shitty obscure Game who only they like Isn't in the listo

>>608751 I think most people were just complaining about COD being on there.

>>608752 CoD post WaW-black ops, mind you, noone would bitch about previus entries.

>>608753 You are free to suggest some other games to replace them, if you want. I gave out my reasons for keeping them, and I have not gotten any notable titles to replace them with, which shows me these anons don't know any games that would. I had others suggest actual, proper video games, and I put them on the list, I don't respect people who say "X sucks" and do not elaborate further, that is cuckchan posting >but you have COD! yes ,and more hours in COD than most people here playing other games so far put together, which is why I think I know a little bit more about this series than them. As a matter of fact, with the kinds of posts we had last threads, before it officially died, I made the list myself initially, based off not just my tastes, but the input of this list and what others generally consider GOTY worthy titles, and it has transformed since it's inception into what you see now. If you have any games to replace the CODs in 2014 or 2020 Honorable lists, I will consider them, unless they are meme indie games or remakes that most people never heard about before. Contributing is always better than simply shitposting, or worse, actually getting upset over the internet Speaking of which >>608751 Someone suggested Darksiders 2 as an honorable game. Looking at the list >>608730 has >Dishonored >Katawa Shoujo >Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed Does anyone here have any experience with any of these games to be able to judge if Darksiders 2 deserves to replace any of them?

>>608727 >I've heard of Wonder boy, obviously. I wasn't aware it was remade, because I don't follow nintendo consoles <Wonder Boy <a franchise developed by Westone, and published by Sega <Sega has been the rights holder since it began Yeah, I'm sure you play real games faggotnigger.

>>608751 Anon, there was no rainbow games released in 2011, neither in 2001 when the first serious game was released, if that was a typo. What are you talking about? This does give me an idea, however. The original Rainbow Six was a revolutionary game, and I think it belongs on the list. The OG game came out in 1998, the arguably superior game, Rogue Spear, came out in 1999. Would anyone subject if for 1998, it replaced SiN or for 1999, it replaced FreeSpace 2?

>>608761 *object

>>608755 COD is irredeemably shit post MW2. Remove them and fix your autism about having 5 games per year. >Dishonored Mediocre game that's basically Thief for normalfags who can't into stealth games. Japs do not need to see how we devolved from games like Thief II and Chaos Theory to some superpowered bullshit that rewards being a loud moron. >>608761 Alternatively, replace Rayman 3 with Rainbow Six: Raven Shield, arguably the last true R6 tacticool game before Ubisoft did a soft reboot with Vegas.

>>608763 5 games per year is not my idea, it was OPs. A lot of the stupid rules are OP's actually, right down to 3 honorable mentions. The only rule I didn't choose was letting every single game make it on the list, which is why the old list looks like it does, a little gategeeping is in order. Much like >Rayman 3 We are choosing Honorary Mentions right now, not Core games. There is a difference >GOTY are the best games released that year, bar none. Game has to have changed the industry or impacted it's genre, or at least been the best game released that year, top none >Core games are directly underneath GOTY, all good on their own accord, just not GOTY. Games have to have some recognition, or impact on the indurstry >Honorable Mentions are the easiest games to change. They are fun, good games that while not as impactful or good, are still worthy of recommendation Most of the old list is an honorable mentions, with sparse core games inbetween, even a GOTY here and there. Right now, Rayman 3 is not up for debate, but any Honorable Mention can be changed. For 2003, it's >Sim City 4 >Postal 2 >Beyond Good & Evil Would you change any of those games for Rainbow Six: Raven Shield? Or object to me changing any games for OG rainbow six games, as I stated here? >>608761

I should add, if there are some really good games in "Honorable Mentions", that's because that was a banger year for gaming, and you literally cannot choose just 5 Good games. This usually occurs in mid 90s and early 2000s, where there are so many games, compromises have to be made, that doesn't mean "Honorable Mentions" are bad by any means. This is what I need help with, we can talk about the core games when Honorable Mentions are largely agreed upon

>>608764 >Right now, Rayman 3 is not up for debate It's not as good as 2. Not bad, but Sim City 4 or Raven Shield would be better games.

>>608768 So, we should change Sim City 4 for Rainbow Six: Raven Shield? Are there any objections? What do you think about Rainbow Six OG games? >>608761 Also, I do agree, Rayman 2 is one of my all time favorite platformers, played it on DS recently, but something feels a bit off about it. Can't put it into words

>>608769 *I may have misread your post, do you mean game OTHER than Sim City should be replaced with Raven Shield? Would it be >Postal 2 or >Beyond Good & Evil if you had to choose?

In fact, just get rid of the fucking honorable mention niggertry. Just post the objectively good games. Nobody, not the CODfag nor OP, should fret about there being some uneven amount for each year. If anything, the lesser good games from the 7th gen onward will show the objective degradation of western games. Fretting about need MUH FIVE GAMES and then trying to wedge in some honorable mentions is just being autistic in the worst unproductive way possible. >>608769 SC4 and Raven should both be there. Hell, keep Rayman 3 while you're at it.

>>608771 >In fact, just get rid of the fucking honorable mention niggertry. Just post the objectively good games. Sorry, I will keep OP's original wishes, even if he is acting like an ex-GF whom I just dumped recently. I should note that this list is getting finalized and made by the end of the week, so this doesn't go on for the next 2 weeks, like it would under OP with his "list". And personally, I would put more games on it, but see >>608679 With the way the list is designed right now, we do not have space for more than 8 games, unless the graphics guy says we can squeeze 2 more honorable mentions, or something to that effect >SC4 and Rave should be there Which of the two >>608770 Should go out, in this case?

>>608751 >For 2011, i'll like some Rainbow Six instead of Sam The only R6 game released in 2011 was Shadow Vanguard for smartphones. Are you mistaking it for GR: Shadow Wars on the 3DS?

>>608774 >mobile shit >some 3ds game nobody has ever heard of lol I will admit, I wouldn't mind if OG ghost recon would make it on the list, tho. Would anybody be opposed to that?

Ghost Recon would be a 2001 game, a tough year since so many good games came out. Here is the Honorary Mentions list, if it made it in >Red Faction >Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 >Conker's Bad Fur Day What do anons think?

>>608763 >Remove them and fix your autism about having 5 games per year I'm actually the one that decided on that number at the creation of this project. >>608771 >In fact, just get rid of the fucking honorable mention niggertry. Just post the objectively good games. So, just have the five on the outset and don't list any honorable mentions for every year? >If anything, the lesser good games from the 7th gen onward will show the objective degradation of western games. Couldn't that also be shown by how Western games shift from AAA products to Indie titles and remakes as the 201X progress? >>608776 >some 3ds game nobody has ever heard of Hey, idiot, people refer to Shadow Wars as one of the best SRPGs around, even countering the later FE titles on the system until Echoes:SoV finally gave people what they wanted.

I feel like Overload deserves more than just an honorable mention for 2018. It's a really good game, but I might be biased because Descent is something I really enjoy.

>>608780 Could switch that with Monster Boy. I just put that in there because people wanted everything but a CoD game. Does that sound agreeable?

>>608779 >one of the best SRPGs around Not that anon, I haven't played it yet but I have a feeling you're overeating the shit out of it I'll check it out sometime to see if you're full of it, people pushed all sorts of bullshit on the 3DS as being better than it was, I rarely saw that game being brought up >Echoes You mean the game that might have had the worst map design out of even the 3DS games? People liked it because its story wasn't shit and it was a pretty good and interesting remake, but they kept in the horrendously bad maps The fun more came from the interesting units, items and clsss differences from most FE games

>>608786 >I have a feeling you're overeating the shit out of it I have to admit that I haven't played it myself (Need to get around to it sometime), but that's from what I heard. Although, you could also attribute much of that praise to the fact that, pickings for strategy games prior to 2012 were absolutely slim, unless you had interest in fantasy-dating SRPGs like the then-recent Record of Agarest (Another game I need to play). For reference, prior to GH:SW, you had Valkyria Chronicles and the last Advanced Wars in 2008 (So, a three year drought), Operation Darkness was 2007, XCOM was dead since 2001, and people were disappointed with the direction the then recent Command & Conquer games were taking. >You mean the game that might have had the worst map design out of even the 3DS games? From what I heard, it was the only decent FE game on either DS system.

Using input for the list, here is what it looks like now. Use >>608730 For reference: 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Unknown Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Jazz Jackrabbit <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Rollercoaster Tycoon <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Grand Theft Auto III* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Halo: Combat Evolved Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Beyond Good & Evil 2004: >Halo 2* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Dishonored <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Crypt of the Necrodancer <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Dishonored 2 <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Disco Elysium* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Risk of Rain 2 Boneworks <Warsaw <Luigi's Mansion 3 <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Among Us* Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Hades Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Deathloop* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Valheim Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks Still waiting on several inputs: >Should GTA 3 or San Andreas get GOTY? It also determines which Halo game, Combat Evolved or 2, gets the reward for their respective Years >>608755 >>608770 >Rainbow Six: Raven Shield and Darksiders 2 have been suggested as Honorable List Mentions >>608780 Can you tell me more about that one? Do you think it deserves an honorary spot for 2018? Choices for that year so far are: >Spyro: Reignited Trilogy >Pathfinder: King Maker >Ion Fury

>>608791 You can change your ID, we still know it's you! To anyone who's curious, we're referring to this list: >>608737

>>608792 Yes, my ID changed, thanks to how this site works. My list still stands, and will be made before yours. I am just waiting for some final suggestions and anon's input

>>608793 >My list still stands No, it doesn't. >and will be made before yours But, it's already made through 2018. >I am just waiting for some final suggestions You're not doing shit. You're ignoring people's suggestions and making your own personal list based on your own feelings rather than what people have to say.

>>608790 >XCOM was dead since 2001 Just did some quick checking and I was wrong on this. The last "true" XCOM game was back in 1998, with the closest thing since being a GBA game by it's creator back in 2005.

>>608792 The list being made right now is this one >>608791 It is currently being finished, today I want to finalize the honorable mentions, tomorrow decide if some honorable mentions and Core games should be switched around, and lastly, decide on sunday if any of the core games should replace GOTY that are currently there(right now, there is a debate between GTA 3 or San Andreas deserving it more) The old list will take weeks, if not months to finalize, and even then I doubt it will look presentable. I did mine in an afternoon and been getting useful information from other anons on how to change it, because I have enough reference which games should be on a list like that, without suggesting something like "tabletop gaming" unironically, like you have last thread. My list will be actually created by the time yours is still in it's infancy, even if the first mockup will be done in MS Paint, so I hope most anons will simply give input on the one that matters more

>>608811 >It is currently being finished It already is finished up through 2018 up here: >>608737 Here, I'll even repost it for you: >/2018/ Ion Fury Kingdom Come: Deliverance Overload Spyro Reignited Trilogy World War 3 >/2017/ A Hat in Time Cuphead Hollow Knight Sonic Mania South Park: The Fractured But Whole >/2016/ Factorio Shadow of the Beast Stardew Valley Superhot Titanfall 2 >/2015/ Crypt of the Necrodancer Downwell Fast Racing NEO Hotline Miami 2 Rocket League >/2014/ Alien: Isolation Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor South Park: The Stick of Truth The Talos Principle Wasteland 2 >/2013/ Battleblock Theater Dead Rising 3 Grand Theft Auto V Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon Rayman Legends >/2012/ Darksiders II Dust: An Elysian Tail Hotline Miami Max Payne 3 The Darkness II >/2011/ Dead Rising 2: Off the Record Deus Ex: Human Revolution Mortal Kombat Rayman Origins Serious Sam 3: BFE >/2010/ Bioshock 2 Darksiders Donkey Kong Country Returns Fallout: New Vegas Halo: Reach >/2009/ Batman: Arkham Asylum Halo Wars Left 4 Dead 2 Prototype Punch-Out!! >/2008/ Audiosurf Dead Space Iron Man Spelunky Saints Row 2 >/2007/ Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Crysis Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl The Orange Box >/2006/ Bully Hitman: Blood Money Marvel: Ultimate Alliance Prey Tomb Raider: Legend >/2005/ Battlefield 2 Burnout Revenge F.E.A.R. SWAT 4 Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory >/2004/ Half Life 2 Halo 2 Grand Theft Auto San Andreas Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates >/2003/ Call of Duty Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX3 Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic >/2002/ Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Metroid Prime Sly Cooper & The Theivius Raccoonus The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind >/2001/ Burnout Halo Max Payne Serious Sam Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II - Rogue Leader >/2000/ American McGee's Alice Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Deus Ex Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine Tony Hawk 2 >/1999/ Age of Empires II Rayman 2 Star Wars Episode I Racer Unreal Tournament Worms Armageddon >/1998/ Apocalypse Spyro the Dragon StarCraft I Thief: The Dark Project Turok 2 >/1997/ Blood Crash Bandicoot 2 Fallout Goldeneye 007 Turok: Dinosaur Hunter >/1996/ Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Civilization II Duke Nukem Quake Tomb Raider >/1995/ Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn Donkey Kong Country 2 Full Throttle MechWarrior 2 Twisted Metal >/1994/ Doom II Earthworm Jim Mega Turrican System Shock X-COM: UFO Unknown >/1993/ Cannon Fodder Doom SimCity 2000 Star Fox The Terminator (SEGA CD) >/1992/ Alone in the Dark Flashback Super Star Wars Ultima VII Wolfenstein 3D

>>608813 Like I said, you can keep doing your little list, and let the thread die again, because you're an autistic nigger, mine is already finished. I will start putting the first touches on it by the end of sunday, if not earlier. Hell, I might learn Graphic Design if I need to, either way, you will have to deal with the fact that a list that has COD games will be better than yours

*almost finished

>>608811 >The old list will take weeks, if not months to finalize That because it takes time to hear people's considerations and apply. >I did mine in an afternoon And, it shows by having games people can attest to being terrible. >and been getting useful information from other anons on how to change it Except, you're not doing that. You're not even hearing the issues other Anons have with what it is that you're doing. >because I have enough reference which games should be on a list like that >without suggesting something like "tabletop gaming" unironically That was because that was the games people had played and recommended. If people had played and recommended other games, then different titles would be listed. Why is that so hard to understand?! >My list will be actually created by the time yours is still in it's infancy So? Just because it's completed sooner doesn't make the list any better. In fact, since you're so intent upon making your own list, how about you abandon this thread and make the entire list, yourself, WITHOUT anyone's input?

>>608816 There is no need for two separate threads for the same thing. You should thank me for bumping this thread, so it doesn't die again, just like I did in the last one. I also hope you realize that no matter how much ANGRY RED TEXT you post, my list is happening, and it is happening quicker than yours. Ergo, why there is no need to bother cluttering up the catalog further when I just need some opinions from the anons here, especially since the last thread is still on page one, since you were so scared I would make the next one

Hmm...GTA San Andreas or III have to be picked huh while also deciding between halo 1 & 2 for GOTY. If we're going to decide on the halo games, are going by the classic Bungie releases or the Master Chief collection released recently? I want to say San Andreas is more memorable as people are still playing the game now & have been going crazy with making mods for it despite Rockstar of David's efforts of sabotages with the "Remaster". I'm not sure III is talked about as much anymore beyond 'It was the first GTA game in 3D & caused controversy for doing things in the open world', I would wager Vice City gets more discussion. As for the Halo games, it could be argued that Halo 2 is more memorable for the online multiplayer & good music. It however sits in the middle of the Halo storyline, so I'm not sure if one needs to play the original game to get everything. I had fun playing the PC port of Halo 1, but it's been such a long time ago. Based on my input, I'm leaning towards GTA Sandreas for 2004 & Halo 1 for 2001 What do you anons think?

>>608819 I don't want to pick Master Chief Collection, since it's literally just remakes of older games, plus it had horrible launch issues. I have no horse in this race, I love all four games involved in GOTY equally, but I think GTA III and Halo 2 were more impactful, former by pretty much inventing the open world genre as we know it today, and latter for doing the same for standardizing what console shooters should look like, not to mention what online play on consoles should look like. Before that, closes to the best console shooter you had was Goldeneye, not to mention the hype Halo 2 had. In comparison GTA San Andreas is pretty much as complete of a game as you can get in GTA III, and has achieved an even bigger cult status, not to mention more controversies, and Halo: Combat Evolved was the prototype for Halo 2, which I mentioned. Lack of online play hurt it a bit in my ranking, but it did take over local split screen maches with friends from Goldeneye anyways. Tough decision Have you considered the recommended games mentioned in >>608791 Specifically, the games being contested for Honorable Mentions now are >Rainbow Six: Raven Shield(2003) >Darksiders II(2012) >Overload(2018)

*as complete as a game can get in GTA III engine

>>608818 >There is no need for two separate threads for the same thing. I didn't say make a second thread, I SAID MAKE THE ENTIRE DAMN THING YOURSELF SINCE YOU'RE SO INTENT UPON IGNORING ON WHAT WAS ALREADY ESTABLISHED! >You should thank me for bumping this thread FUCK OFF!!! The thread was already getting bumped without your normalfag autism. >my list is happening Like I said, go right ahead and make the entire damn thing yourself. However, you are not using this thread to do it. >>608819 >If we're going to decide on the halo games, are going by the classic Bungie releases or the Master Chief collection released recently? The original games as the MCC is just inferior ports of the originals, axes content that the original games had, and is still broken. >Based on my input, I'm leaning towards GTA Sandreas for 2004 & Halo 1 for 2001 Don't have issue with that, but GTA3 isn't listed here: >>608813

>T-This is my list! Stop!! Jesus nigger, get the hint Personally, I don't think Overload belongs on the Honorary Mentions, at least not replacing the other ones for that year. We already have Descent 1 and 2 anyways I could see Darksiders II replacing Katawa Shoujo, but that might upset some anons. Has anyone here who played it can vouch for it? Similarly, Rainbow Six: Raven Shield feels redundant, since we have Rainbow Six 1 already. I could see it replacing Beyond Good & Evil. I don't think that's a good idea, while personally not my cup of tea, it is definitely a unique little game, and deserves an honorable mention. We still need a tie breaker for the GTA III and San Andreas question, unless someone else has any other games They want to suggest for Honorable Mention that aren't there yet Reminder, the old list has a lot of games, I know some of you voted for them. Now is the time >>608738

>>608826 >GTA3 isn't listed here In that case, I'll stand by what I'm leaning on. As far as honorable mentions go... 2003 <haven't played Beyond Good & Evil >Postal 2 is a game that is an acquired taste, it does have a Japanese release if it helps <Sim City 4 is not a bad game (esecially given the later DRM-infested reboot) but it's inferior to the classic Sim City games like 2000 2012 <never played Dishonored >Katawa Shoujo would likely be up their alley of games >Sonic and All-Stars Racing Transformed should stay, it's already been explained how good of a kart racer it is, just as good as Mario Kart 2018 >the arguement has been laid for Spyro: Reignited Trilogy as it finally lets them play Spyro 3 & the other games in the way they were supposed to without all the terrible changes that plagued the PSX originals in Japan <haven't played Pathfinder: Kingmaker <haven't played Ion Fury

>>608828 >T-This is my list! Stop!! THIS IS NOT MY LIST, THIS IS THE LIST THAT OTHER ANONS HAVE CREATED THROUGH THE COMBINED EFFORT OF, NOW, THREE THREADS! The list you keep post, this list up here: >>608791 That is ENTIRELY your own list, that YOU solely created, without any input or collaboration from other Anons. >Personally No one gives a shit what you personally think. According to your own opinion, Call of Duty should belong in every single spot for the "best" of every subsequent year, and you're only backing down now because people have caught onto what your doing and are telling you to fuck off back to where you came from! >>608830 I was considering this Anon's opinion of disregarding the "Honorable mentions" given how there's already 150 games just from the five best alone: >>608771

>>608830 So what you're saying is >Beyond Good & Evil should be replaced with Rainbow Six: Raven Shield for 2003 >Dishonored should be replaced with Darksiders 2 for 2012 Does anybody have a problem with this? Any other suggestions? Overload will be kept on a backburner for now, as I don't see enough people saying either Ion Fury or Pathfinder should go

>>608832 >So what you're saying is What's being said it to fuck off back to the hole you crawled out of!

Also, reminder that GOTY will be voted on sunday, once both Honorable Mentions and Core games will be finalized >>608791 As you can see, there is only one COD "in the final spot", and it's the one everyone has agreed deserves that place. I have also removed 2 COD games from the initial list, as well as many others I voted for, and even removed one from the Honorable Mentions list itt, as I am trying to be as impartial as possible. The only caveat is that I want to at least hear a reason why X should be in, or Y should be out, so that the list can be finished within days, not weeks, and so that we don't end up with 150+ entries Today, we are finalizing Honorable Mentions(red text games), tomorrow, deciding if Core games and Honorable games should switch spots(that includes COD games, if anons feel that way)

Once, again, here is the final list for 1992-2018: >/2018/ Ion Fury Kingdom Come: Deliverance Overload Spyro Reignited Trilogy World War 3 >/2017/ A Hat in Time Cuphead Hollow Knight Sonic Mania South Park: The Fractured But Whole >/2016/ Factorio Shadow of the Beast Stardew Valley Superhot Titanfall 2 >/2015/ Crypt of the Necrodancer Downwell Fast Racing NEO Hotline Miami 2 Rocket League >/2014/ Alien: Isolation Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor South Park: The Stick of Truth The Talos Principle Wasteland 2 >/2013/ Battleblock Theater Dead Rising 3 Grand Theft Auto V Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon Rayman Legends >/2012/ Darksiders II Dust: An Elysian Tail Hotline Miami Max Payne 3 The Darkness II >/2011/ Dead Rising 2: Off the Record Deus Ex: Human Revolution Mortal Kombat Rayman Origins Serious Sam 3: BFE >/2010/ Bioshock 2 Darksiders Donkey Kong Country Returns Fallout: New Vegas Halo: Reach >/2009/ Batman: Arkham Asylum Halo Wars Left 4 Dead 2 Prototype Punch-Out!! >/2008/ Audiosurf Dead Space Iron Man Spelunky Saints Row 2 >/2007/ Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Crysis Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl The Orange Box >/2006/ Bully Hitman: Blood Money Marvel: Ultimate Alliance Prey Tomb Raider: Legend >/2005/ Battlefield 2 Burnout Revenge F.E.A.R. SWAT 4 Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory >/2004/ Half Life 2 Halo 2 Grand Theft Auto San Andreas Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates >/2003/ Call of Duty Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX3 Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic >/2002/ Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Metroid Prime Sly Cooper & The Theivius Raccoonus The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind >/2001/ Burnout Halo Max Payne Serious Sam Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II - Rogue Leader >/2000/ American McGee's Alice Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Deus Ex Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine Tony Hawk 2 >/1999/ Age of Empires II Rayman 2 Star Wars Episode I Racer Unreal Tournament Worms Armageddon >/1998/ Apocalypse Spyro the Dragon StarCraft I Thief: The Dark Project Turok 2 >/1997/ Blood Crash Bandicoot 2 Fallout Goldeneye 007 Turok: Dinosaur Hunter >/1996/ Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Civilization II Duke Nukem Quake Tomb Raider >/1995/ Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn Donkey Kong Country 2 Full Throttle MechWarrior 2 Twisted Metal >/1994/ Doom II Earthworm Jim Mega Turrican System Shock X-COM: UFO Unknown >/1993/ Cannon Fodder Doom SimCity 2000 Star Fox The Terminator (SEGA CD) >/1992/ Alone in the Dark Flashback Super Star Wars Ultima VII Wolfenstein 3D

Thinking about this and how the autist refuses to leave, why does this seem like a similar situation to what's going on with the DNF rebuild that's being destroyed thanks to trannies, furries, and fags infiltrating the project; and how all those fags keep trying to restart the project under a different banner but keep being outed: >>607358

I have come up with some design ideas for the games that never saw an official release in Japan, but have JP patches made to add their language to the games. What do you anons think?

>>608849 Are you the anon that is the graphic designer from last thread? Are you open to actually developing the list as is, once it is finalized? I am sure that creating a working template will also benefit that list, as I don't see too many games being different between the two(chief difference is mine will be done quicker). >>608791 It is pretty much done, with minor differences here and there, but I noticed the very early games, 1992-1997 are pretty much untouched, so if you're interested, you could start making those for the list, and giving us a look how the final product will look like, maybe we can even give you feedback on what we see. Even if there are going to be changes, they will likely be minor, as we are agreeing on most things, anyways As for the icons, I like the designs of them. I don't know what you have in store, as far as what kinds of icons we will have for the list, so I can't help you there. I do definitely appreciate going a mile above and actually making the list look pretty Since another anon asked, would it be possible to expand the list to, say, 10 instead of 8? Some are frustrated their picks aren't going thru, and I don't see why we can't have 5 honorary picks, that is unless that will be too much work for you, and others who might get involved with actually designing the list once it is finished

>>608849 I get the sub icon, but what does the dub icon mean?

>>608849 For the "dub" icon why don't you use a guy with a cowboy hat to represent the West and a guy with one of those feudal japanese lord hairstyles to represent the East?

>>608854 Personally, I think the simplistic design of flags could work, cats with rounded eyes could have jap flags and ones with round eyes american or british flags. This is probably a horrible idea, but that's what I think anyways, but I wouldn't be against feudal/cowboy hat idea, either

Here is the list so far, updated. Again, please look at >>608791 For reference what was changed 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Unknown Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Jazz Jackrabbit <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Rollercoaster Tycoon <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Grand Theft Auto III* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Halo: Combat Evolved Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Halo 2* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Crypt of the Necrodancer <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Dishonored 2 <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Disco Elysium* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Risk of Rain 2 Boneworks <Warsaw <Luigi's Mansion 3 <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Among Us* Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Hades Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Deathloop* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Valheim Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks If you have any other changes you want to make, let it be known now. The red text games are "Honorable Mentions", which anons pick out if any other games get deserve to be there, keeping in mind a whole lot of games from >>608738 Have been mentioned in the past, so if you think they should be on this list, now is the time. Another ongoing debate is if GTA III or San Andreas deserves the GOTY award more, that also impacts if Halo 2 or Halo Combat Evolved get it in their respective years. We have a tie, and a tie breaker would be appreciated, it doesn't matter to me either way as I think both choices are correct.

>>608852 >Are you the anon that is the graphic designer from last thread? yes >Are you open to actually developing the list as is, once it is finalized? I am sure that creating a working template will also benefit that list, as I don't see too many games being different between the two(chief difference is mine will be done quicker). I'll look into it. >It is pretty much done, with minor differences here and there, but I noticed the very early games, 1992-1997 are pretty much untouched, so if you're interested, you could start making those for the list, and giving us a look how the final product will look like, maybe we can even give you feedback on what we see. Even if there are going to be changes, they will likely be minor, as we are agreeing on most things, anyways That sounds fair. What I'll need to do first though, is look up the release dates, the country flags of the developers, & the genres in Japanese. Then it's a matter of copying & pasting them to the chart. Here is an example of the format. >Star Wars KOTR >開発元: BioWare (Developer goes here) >生産国: 🇨🇦 (Country flag goes here) >発売日: 2003年7月15日 (Release date goes here. The format is Year/Month/Day, and I go by first release date no matter if Europe, USA, or Japan got it first) >ジャンル : アクションRPG (Genre goes here. Anons are more than welcome to put them in English while I look for their Japanese counterpart) >>608853 >what does the dub icon mean? Like the JP patch, it adds Japanese voices to the games if it never came with any. Thinking about it now, it's rather unlikely they'll be found in the open unless the nips themselves did a fan dub, perhaps it can be ignored. I discovered Japanese dubbed lines for the Medic by sheer accident

That sounds pretty good, anon. 2003 list should be mostly the same, COD has been removed and so was Burnout, with Sim City 4 and Rainbow Six: Raven Shield taking their place, so this simple change should be a good test to see if the final list will look good. japanese medic just sounds wrong, I just can't imagine him with a different voice now

Ignore this list for everything except 2019-2021: >>608860 This is the list for everything else: >>608838

>>608866 both lists will be done. Mine will be finished quicker, so whenever yours is done, mine will be edited to reflect yours, in the same format I wager, unless requests are made, and we can have two lists. Please stop melting down, this is literally a win-win situation

>>608868 >Mine will be finished quicker >mine will be edited to reflect yours >Please stop melting down Sounds like one autist is losing his mind, and it isn't me.

>>608865 >>608861 not sure what happened there Also, I know you know this already, when looking at >>608860 , but the difference between the current list and your mockup pic, linked for reference, is: >COD replaced with Rayman 3(seen below already) >Rayman's empty spot and Burnout replaced with Sim City 4 and Rainbow Six, Raven Shield The list identical otherwise for that year. Just making sure, to avoid the confusion. A question, if a unique japanese cover is available, like with Prince of Persia here, you will obviously use that, but if both western and japanese are identical, other than the title, will you just use western english covers?

>>608854 >>608855 Here's the feudal/cowbay designs & cat designs. >>608865 >spoiler He also has a real German voice >>608881 >if both western and japanese are identical, other than the title, will you just use western english covers? Japanese covers get priority unless their version of the game is censored or inferior to the other regions.

>>608883 I see. Just wanted to ask, since KOTOR, Max Payne 2 and the honorable mentions had western covers, and thought it was just a placeholder thing. For these particular games, are the covers finalized, if I am understanding you correctly? I like the icons, you clearly have the most experience than us in this sort of thing. I don't mind if the cowboys or cats get chosen, they both look good(maybe the latter can be used for something else, like text instead of dubs, I dunno) This medic actually sounds fine, but I kinda expected that

>>608676 >>608679 >>608730 >No WWF No Mercy I'm dissapointed in all of you

>>608890 I love that game

>>608890 I'm not an expert on wrasslin games. The Honorable Mentions for 2000 are >Colin Mcrae Rally 2.0 >Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine >Perfect Dark If you had to replace any of these games, which would you pick? Also, for everyone else, we're editing Honorable Mentions right now. In interests of time(why my list is getting created), I will stop all suggestions at 00:00 MDT, so that's about 9 hours for you euros. After that, we will decide if Core games deserve their place or if some Honorable Mentions, new or old, should switch places(note, that doesn't mean thrown out, just replaced. I know COD games on the list are controversial, so you can peg them down, if you think that's what they deserve). On sunday, we will finish off the list by deciding if any GOTY games should be changed, only counting Core games we finalized a day before. After sunday, the list will be done, all time cut offs are 00:00 MDT Also, right now, we need tie breakers on if GTA III or San Andreas deserves GOTY the most, that also effects if Halo: Combat evolved or Halo 2 will get GOTY. The list for reference is here >>608860

>>608890 WWF No Mercy is a Japanese developed game though, so they're technically correct leaving it out.

>>608896 Well shit, would you look at that Are there any other good wresslin games that were actually made by westerners? Not sure what the licencing deal was at the time, so maybe all the good ones(read: not 2K) were made overseas

>>608896 They have japanese versions on n64 too under NJPW banner so yeah, not worth adding

>>608883 I sort of favor the feudal/cowboy icons over the cats, but I think the Nips would be more receptive to the cats.

>>608899 I vouch for WWE All-Stars(2011), it's the only triple A pure western developed wrestling title I've played, but it's good fun.

>>608904 Suggestions for 2011 are >inFamous 2 >Deus Ex: Human Revolution >Dead Rising 2: Off The Record so unless people really hate one of those, I think you will have a hard time getting it in there. That's the problem with the 8 game yearly limit, sometimes so many good titles get released, it's hard to get all the ones people want. The exact opposite happens towards the end of the list

How are you going to send this list? To whom?

>>608884 >are the covers finalized, if I am understanding you correctly? Yeah. It will get tricky, however, if the games chosen have a Japanese release only on one particular console & that particular console port is dogshit, leaving other versions to be superior. A quick example would be Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time with the nips only getting the PS2 port while the rest have Gamecube & Xbox ports. The same thing can be said of games on PC. If the original PC release is dogshit, but patches have been made to fix the problems to where it's fully playable, it should be compiled. >I don't mind if the cowboys or cats get chosen, they both look good(maybe the latter can be used for something else, like text instead of dubs, I dunno) The cats could work on Subs, assuming anons like cats more than the generic box as seen in >>608849 (I got that one from looking at the back of DVDs)

>>608907 I have no problem with cowboys and samurais for dubs, and cats used for subs. >>608906 I'm curious for that one myself. Unless you live in japan, spreading this on their social media, gaming related forums or discussion boards or on the 2chan/5chan imageboards are the best bet. Either way, it will be a good list no matter who you are

>>608905 Oh well, I tried; Sorry wrestlebros

>>608908 I changed the look of the western cat to make it look more unique. Besides working on the download icons which I can do on my own, I think this is about the final design of them. In the meantime, whether the lists get debated or not, work will have to be done in compiling information for the games to copy to the charts as seen in >>608861 >Star Wars KOTR (Game Title goes here) >開発元: BioWare (Developer goes here) >生産国: 🇨🇦 (Country flag goes here) >発売日: 2003年7月15日 (Release date goes here. The format is Year/Month/Day, and I go by first release date no matter if Europe, USA, or Japan got it first) >ジャンル : アクションRPG (Genre goes here. Anons are more than welcome to put them in English while I look for their Japanese counterpart)

>Disco Elysium is somehow GOTY 2019 >a game with 1 vote across all three threads >and several anons clearly voting against >Noita got several votes and isn't even on the list Kill yourself OP

>>608934 >Kill yourself OP That's the CoD nigger, NOT me.

>>608934 Not OP, whoops. That said, a fag who picks Red Dead Redemption 2 and Far Cry 5 yet doesn't even include Overload should have no say about good games.

>>608915 I like the designs. Once my list is finalized, I will help you out. For reference, do screenshots and game box art has to be certain sizes for you to use them, or does anything go, as long as it's of good quality? >>608934 I have thrown this list together fairly quickly, I will admit, and it was hard to find a GOTY for the last few years, this is why I am asking for further input. I have no attachment to Disco Elysium, Which of these games would you replace for Noita? >Warsaw >Luigi's Mansion >The Outer Wilds We can vote for GOTY picks on sunday, as I suppose a few games will be moved around from "Honorary Mentions" and "Core Games" If you have any other games you voted for in previous threads, but don't see, let me know

As far as Overload goes, we already have Descent 1 and 2, if you would like to put it for 2018, it would have to replace >Ion Fury or >Pathfinder: Kingmaker as anons felt strongly about Spyro collection, but neither really claimed the other 2

>>608944 >I will admit, and it was hard to find a GOTY for the last few years, this is why I am asking for further input. No, you're not. You're only taking "input" because several Anons have all collectively told you to fuck off.

>>608944 >>608948 As far as the list is concerned, you're STILL intent upon using your own shitty list: >>608860 When we already have a list defined all the way up here: >>608838

>>608942 Yeah, sorry. I realized my mistake too late.

Now, if we're going to do this properly, akin to how the previous threads considered adding games, like you keep "insisting" that we "should", here's the contenders Anons have recommended for 2019, 2020, and 2021: 2019 >Boneworks A first-person physics based action game >Call of Duty: Modern Warfare >Chernobylite >Gato Roboto A open-world side-scrolling run and gun game >Indivisible >Into the Radius VR A survival FPS >Katana Zero >Noita >Outer Wilds A space exploration simulator that loops every 20 minutes >Risk of Rain 2 A survival-based rogue-like 3D platformer with multiplayer >The Outer Worlds >Warsaw 2020 >Call of Duty: Black Ops - Cold War >Carrion A side-scrolling evolution game where the player becomes an ever-increasingly larger monster >Cyber Hook >Ghost of Tsushima An open-world RPG with stealth elements >Ghostrunner >Half-Life: Alyx >Helltaker >Hylics 2 An isometric turn-based RPG with exploration elements >Iron Harvest >Mount and Blade Bannerlord An open-world medieval RPG with hack & slash and strategy elements >Project Wingman A flight combat simulator >Streets of Rage 4 >Ultrakill A first-person character action games focusing on the usage of guns >Wasteland 3 2021 >Aeterna Noctis A side-scrolling open-world 2D beat 'em up >Aliens: Fireteam Elite >Biomutant >Deathloop >Ghostrunner A first-person hack & slash with platforming elements >Intravenous A top-down stealth based shooter based upon clearing each level of enemies >It takes two A cooperative full 3D puzzle platformer >Kaze and the Wild Masks >Madness Nexus Project A top-down twin stick shooter >Stronghold: Warlords The games you just see here is just a sampling of the games that came out for their respective years in case you played one of them and forgot. You are not restricted to choosing only from one of the games listed as far as considering games that should be included on the "Best of the West" list.

>>608962 RoR 2 is breddy gud. Ultrakill is amazingly good. Stellar recommendation from me. Also, add Hades under 2020. It's pretty good. Biomutant is also nice. And here's some more notable releases in that timeframe, for anons trying to remember: >2019 <Control <Yooka-Laylee and the Impossible Lair I can't give my personal opinion, but I've heard it's much better than Yooka-Laykee >2020 <Shantae and the Seven Sirens <Ori and the Will of the Wisps <Dreams (PS4) >2021 <Evil Genius 2 <Necromunda Really interested in this one but it's still on my backlog. <Death's Door <Axiom Verge 2 <Sable BotW clone, saw it mentioned in a Moebius discussion. <Serious Sam 4 <Inscryption

>>608988 Another game some anons might recommend for 2019: <Hypnospace Outlaw

I went through the list from >>608838 & added as much information as I could find! Please look at the txt file & let me know if everything looks correct. Genres will be added later. Some games also need some claifications!

There is about 5 hours to change the "Honorable Mentions" on the Chart. The list in question looks like this right now >>608860 Here is what is currently Contested >Overload(2018) >Niota(2019) see >>608944 >>608948 For more details Next, I noticed there is universal disdain shown towards Disco Elysiym, GOTY for 2019. I have no love for it, either, which is why I want to remove it. I want one of the games in the 2019 list to replace it >Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) >Outer Worlds >Risk of Rain 2 >Boneworks >Warsaw >Luigi's Mansion 3 >The Outer Wilds The game will be removed from the list entirely, so we are looking for a brand new game altogether for 2019, which will replace the GOTY, if you have something else you would like to vote GOTY for 2019 that is not on the list, then please suggest it now Lastly, we still need a tie breaker for GTA III or GTA San Andreas, only one can be GOTY. >>609052 I will take a look at this

Actually, scratch that, I guess we can just add Niota to 2019 list by default. I guess select GOTY from the list I already mentioned, plus Niota. Honorable mentions still welcome

>>609052 If we're going by the standards of early access being the launch for some of these games(like Ion Fury, for example), then WW2 technically "released) on Oct 19, 2018 Factorio gets more complicated, as the steam early access released in 2016(february 25th, if it released the same day as the trailer), but it entered pre alpha that people could supposedly pay for and play as early as 2013, the video on their youtube page was released on february 1st Rock Paper Shotgun article confirms 2016 being early access date https://archive.ph/P4hSX As for Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, it is widely agreed that the PC version is the best, I think, which was developed by KnowWonder, a Californian company. I think all games released worldwide on november 15th, 2002 Obviously, there are a few games here not on the list, that might be on mine, but I will compile these games afterwards, once the list is finalized.

>>608988 see >>609071 If you can vouch for Risk of Rain 2, do you think it could be a contender for GOTY of 2019? If that were the case, would anyone object to it? I have to admit that "Among Us", another GOTY for 2020, was a very quick choice I had to make when going to work, and I regret it. Since you suggested Ultrakill, and I can vouch that it's a good game, I think I will throw Among Us out, just like Disco Elysium That would leave a game that would also need to be voted GOTY for 2020. Here are the choices: >Ultrakill >Wasteland 3 >Ghostrunner >Hades >Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) >Iron Harvest >Black Mesa >Call of Duty: Cold War

>>608860 I want to ask this to anyone who enjoys Luigi's Mansion games: I don't have any experience with them, but I put it as a title for 2019, Luigi's Mansion 3, because I wanted at least one on the list. Which one would be the best choice, if only one could make it on the list?

>>609071 >Lastly, we still need a tie breaker for GTA III or GTA San Andreas, only one can be GOTY. I've said my piece here >>608819 >>609080 Updated again. >>609127 I would personally stick with Dark Moon as 3 didn't really grab my interest.

>>609092 > I have to admit that "Among Us", another GOTY for 2020, was a very quick choice I had to make when going to work AMOGUS came out in 2018

>>609146 >Downwell [Japanese Indie?] FUCK! Need to replace that with a Western 2015 game. Refering to this list, the options are: <Axoim Verge <Call of Duty: Black Ops III <Fallout 4 <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Pixel Heroes <Skyhill

>>609146 Unfortunately, that would be a 2013 game, and that year is very busy. I thought that the original was made by westerners, for some reason, but it wasn't, so 3 it is. >>609150 Point of reference for the initial list was that I made it on my way out to work, with 2018-2021 literally 10-15 minutes before having to leave, and I still had to shave. Some questionable choices were made, but at that point in time, last thread was literally dead, OP wasn't responding, and I made every choice between 2018-2019, it felt like. Some choices were questionable, but I used the initial list as a frame of reference, and thankfully, it was shaped into looking better than it was, but I still wish it had gotten more input from anons

>>609153 I don't mind Black Ops III being put in since it was regarded as the swan song of CoD last thread.

It is way past 00:00 MDT, and there has been zero engagement from others for hours, so I will be slowly wrapping up the questions for input on Honorable Mentions on the list. Doing much needed changes to 2019 and 2020, this is the new list. Keep in mind I can't really decide what the GOTY for 2020 is, and I want to be impartial here 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Unknown Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Jazz Jackrabbit <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Rollercoaster Tycoon <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Grand Theft Auto III* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Halo: Combat Evolved Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Halo 2* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Crypt of the Necrodancer <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Dishonored 2 <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Risk of Rain 2* Niota Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Boneworks <Warsaw <Luigi's Mansion 3 <The Outer Wilds 2020: Ultrakill Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Hades Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Deathloop* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Valheim Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks I've got an errand to run. When I get back, the suggestions for Honorable Mentions(Red Text, Bottom Three) will be closed, so speak now or forever hold your peace. Today, we will be focusing on if Core games and Honorable mentions deserve their places, meaning essentially the difference between which games are best of that year and which are personal recommendations. It will be harder to suggest new games or remove old ones at that point, as I want this list finalized by the end of the week, so if there is anything you want to suggest, now would be the time

>>609146 The problem here is that there is no engagement on the GTA GOTY issue other than between us, so it's 1 to 1 on either game being the one for GOTY. Unfortunately, this board isn't as active anymore as I would like, and even when it is, people rarely suggest anything worthwhile, this has been an issue in the last thread, before it finally died. OP should have thought this through, and at the very least asked sleepychan /v/ and PLW's /geimu/ board for some much needed feeback as well, but it's too late for that now. I will respect the wishes of anybody else who wants to have a say on this topic, otherwise I will keep it at GTA III. Issue will be kept around till the end, Sunday, since it relates to a GOTY

>>609214 Based on a quick gameplay video & reading a few reviews, Hades seems like a safe choice.

>>609217 Noted. I thought so too, but I never played it

>>608839 yeah, 526a81 does seem like quite the breathing detriment

THE FINAL LIST, AS IT STANDS 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Unknown Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Jazz Jackrabbit <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Rollercoaster Tycoon <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Grand Theft Auto III* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Halo: Combat Evolved Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Halo 2* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Crypt of the Necrodancer <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Dishonored 2 <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Risk of Rain 2* Niota Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Boneworks <Warsaw <Luigi's Mansion 3 <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Hades* Ultrakill Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Deathloop* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Valheim Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks In the interest of time, there will be NO CHANGES TO IT from this point on. There is way too little input from the anons here anymore, and it's clear few played games for the latter half of 2010s, vast majority of input from time before that is ALREADY ON THE LIST, EVEN INITIALLY Now that Honorable Mentions are closed, we will focus on Core Games. See this Mockup, once again, to see the difference between tiers: >Honorable Mentions at the bottom, those have been decided >Core games are top 4 games >GOTY is denoted by a crown That said, Core games get more spotlight than Honorable Mentions, so it would be wise to decide which games out of the chosen ones /v/ supports the most. Again, very basic gatekeeping rules in place, I want a short reason why one game should be replaced with another, to show you actually played both of these games. Core and Honorable Mentions considerations will be cut off at 00:00 MDT, much like before. >>609052 The list should be considered finalized, at this point. I can take a quick glance to see which games need info added. You seem to have made lots of progress with designing the list yesterday, would you say you would be ready to actually work on it at this moment? From now on, only spots of these games might change, not the actual titles

>>609222 Hold on a second I know I said my piece earlier, but GTA 3 lost against Halo 1 when the games were being voted in the first thread.

>>609217 why the hell do you keep engaging with the codfag, the fuck is wrong with you?

>>609222 that is not and will never be the final list you usurping nigger

>>609223 wow, took you a fucking while to realize that 526a81(previously a62209) is not only not the creator of this fucking project(that would be a62209), but a subnormal that keeps insisting that HIS list is SO much better and faster that what everyone else has been working on all these threads, here is something else that you might not have noticed: he's the codnigger.

>>609226 I'm retarded. However, there's still one spot to fill for a 2015 game as mentioned in >>609153. If Black Ops III is shit, what should take the spot? <Axoim Verge <Fallout 4 <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Pixel Heroes <Skyhill

>>609223 If that's the case, I will count Halo: Combat Evolved as GOTY for 2001, and GTA San Andreas for GOTY in 2004 There is a bit of the issue, Diablo was released in Early 1997, not 1996 as I originally thought. Should Diablo be kept for 1997, and if so, what should take it's place? >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto That means there is a vacancy for 1996 right now >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo(Missing) Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst

Another technicality, Myst originally released on Mac in 1993, I must have misclicked the year when I originally typed that in Here are games from 1993 >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II Should any of them be removed for Myst? If so, which game should take it's place for 1996? as for >>609232 I would suggest removing Tetrisphere or Grand Theft Auto for Diablo. Would anyone object to that?

>>609146 Here are the games I noticed that are on the list, but weren't in your PDF >>609214 Tell me if there is anything wrong, or if you need screenshots or boxart of them.

>>609232 >>609237 Before the list is finalized, here are the years with games that need your input: 1993 >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II Myst was originally on the list, but was put in the wrong place. Should it be on the list, and if so, which game should it replace? 1996 >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Diablo(Missing) Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Myst(Missing) We need games for this year. Here is what the anons have chosen in the previous threads >Quake >Crash Bandicoot >Killer Instinct 2 >Master of Orion 2: Battle At Antares >Twisted Metal 2 Please choose 2 of the above, or suggest your own Lastly, here is a list for 1997 >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Shadow Warrior Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto Should Diablo replace any of these?

>>609261 Since nobody is contributing, here is my two cents: >I do think Myst definitely needs to be mentioned, but I don't see any games for this year I would want to remove. Technically, the game came out in 1993 only on Mac, most people played it on PC, and that version came out in 1994. Here are the games for that year >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Defense Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Jazz Jackrabbit <Star Wars: TIE Fighter I don't see anyone supporting Jazz Jackrabbit or Star Wars: TIE Fighter, so I think one of these could be removed. >1996 I heard people wanted Quake in, and I think Crash Bandicoot deserves a mention. I am not familiar with Killer Instincts too much(was a Mortal Kombat guy), and Twisted Metal 1 is already on the list >1997 Diablo 2 is already on the list, and GOTY contender at that, so I don't think Diablo 1 needs to be on this list Speaking of which, I did notice that people here prefer Blood to Shadow Warrior, as far as Build Engine FPS games of that era. If we were to swap these two, would anyone object?

>>608675 I came into this thread expecting a shitshow, I was not disappointed unsurprisingly I was able to figure out a game that was missing after a quick skim. >supreme commander >warzone 2100 >monkeys island I know you guys are gonna be fags about these these lists so I'm just throwing these out there

>>609298 >Supreme Commander It came out in a year with too many good games, sorry. >Warzone 2100 I can't really see any games off the top of my head deserve to go away for this title, unless we remove Rollercoaster Tycoon 1, due to Rollercoaster Tycoon 2, already being on the list >Monkey Island You will have to be more specific here, original came out in 1990, when the first entries from the list are from 1992 Also, see >>609271 In the interest of time, and due to the inactivity of this board, I am going to finalize what I said here, unless someone has a problem with this. The whole reason I'm doing this list is so that this won't take forever, if people don't have anything to say, then they shouldn't be surprised if their voices aren't heard

Here is the list as it stands now 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones And The Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Defense Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Myst <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Crash Bandicoot Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Quake 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Blood Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Warzone 2100 <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Halo: Combat Evolved* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Grand Theft Auto III Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Halo 2 <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Crypt of the Necrodancer <Just Cause 3 <Ori and the Blind Forest <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Dishonored 2 <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Risk of Rain 2* Noita Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Boneworks <Warsaw <Luigi's Mansion 3 <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Hades* Ultrakill Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Deathloop* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Valheim Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks I am pretty happy with how it turned out, and I appreciate the feedback. I know it started a little rough, but I did make the base relatively quickly. With how inactive the thread has been getting, even before I decided to make the new list, I think this will be the final iteration. Not everyone will agree, but they had time to speak up. Most didn't, I listened to those that did The next order of business is deciding if every game deserves the spot it has. Let me explain, The top game is GOTY(it will be decided tomorrow), four games beneath it are Core games, and the last three games, in redtext, are "Honorable Mentions. This is all largely semantics, all games on this list are good and deserve to be there, but the difference between the two is determining the kind of game you would recommend out of personal taste, or a recommendation that is more universally agreed upon. GOTY is obviously the best of the best, and if anyone wants to contest any of these titles, it will be done tomorrow Please see >>609222 For reference how this cart will likely look Voting on Core Game placement ends same as yesterday, 00:00 MDT timezone. For reference, I give this about 12 hours from this point on, then we move on to the GOTY mentions. There was debate over, for example, which GTA game between 3 and San Andreas deserved GOTY title the most, so I assume tomorrow will look something like that

>>609339 >>609390 go fuck yourself codnigger

>>609390 Reminder, there is about 4 more hours to change Honorable Mentions and Core games around. The thread has seen zero activity, but if you have some input to give, now is the time

>>609589 >Reminder, there is about 4 more hours to change Honorable Mentions and Core games around. The thread has seen zero activity, but if you have some input to give, now is the time

Why the fuck are there so many downright atrocious, awful AAA games. More than half of these games should be thrown in the trash and not played by anyone let alone suggested to nips. Is this bait? Are you making a list of bad games?

>No Grim Dawn in either OP's Image or this shitty thread It's only, argueably of course, the best Diablo-like ARPG ever made. >No Front Mission 3 in OP's Image >Snootgame but no Unteralterbach You underage faggots disgust me.

>>609731 Cakekike needs to actually do his fucking job and ban the cuckchan kiddies that have been infesting the board.

>>608691 >Bernd and the mystery of Unteralterbach if youre trying to get nips to actually play the game you gotta give them the shit they actually like that is ero games

>>609677 Because years have to be filled out regardless of quality.

>>609847 No, it's because the CoDnigger insists that AAA games are the only "real" games that ever exist. See here: >>608727 >I play real video games

>>609677 I have been asking people for input for several days now. I have neither gotten a response as to what games should be removed, nor what they should be replaced WITH. The only exception to that would be people complaining about why COD games need to be removed from the list, and I haven't gotten an explanation why, other than "it's cod", which is not an acceptable answer. The suggestions I was given were also pretty mediocre, something that could maybe make it to "Honorable Mentions" but not core games. I did remove one COD game as there was one decent suggestion, tho, otherwise, I couldn't even get people to tell me if Overload should make it for 2018's list, as nobody could tell me if it could replace any of the 2018's Honorable Mentions, likely because they never played any of these games, I assume. >>609731 >Grim Dawn I said I'm done taking suggestions for the list, but the game is based off Titan Quest engine, part of the same genre, and I can vouch for Titan quest(and it is not on the list). Since it is a 2016 game, and people are complaining about "Mainstream Trash", I can remove Dishonored 2 and put Grim Dawn in it's place, if nobody minds. No, I am not removing Infinite Warfare, as I made my case about why it should stay, and nobody really made a counter point. Current list, for reference >>609390 >Front Mission Japanese game, so we can't put it on the list >Snoot Game or Unterlaterbach I don't believe VNs are real video games, and frankly, if people wanted them included, we should have done this by GENREs, not YEARS, as >>609847 and others pointed out. That said, we do have Katawa Shoujo for 2012 >>609792 I wouldn't be opposed to creating a list of best Ero games, but this is clearly not what this thread is about. Right now, I just want to finish this list, this has gone on long enough, and it's clear most of the people involved don't know what they're talking about, so I am simply going to ship what we have. If people aren't happy with what's on the list, they had their chance to speak their mind, literally nobody but maybe one person replied to this thread, and all he did was greentext like a cuckchanner

>>609851 *replied yesterday

>>609390 I haven't gotten any comments yesterday concerning if Core games and Honorable Mentions(red text) should be switched around, so I will just assume everybody is happy with their current spot Last order of business before the list is actually put into work is deciding if any of the games that are GOTY deserve that spot. There was some debate over GTA San Andreas and GTA III, but other than that, I think this is the most agreed upon part of the list. Since GOTYs are arguably the most important titles, please let me know if you think any of these should be switched. I see plenty of people being critical, but very few actually trying to offer any changes, you should be able to give a short explanation as to why you think any title doesn't deserve it's GOTY, if you are to be taken seriously. Nobody is asking for an essay, just a short post, to see if you know what you're talking about

That should be obvious, but you should also offer what game that title should be replaced WITH, which is on the list provided, and why it deserves to be there more.

Reminder that there are about 8 more hours before the list is finalized, and both this thread, and this board, is fucking dead. It's a Sunday, I really expected better The list as it stands now, and what is going on >>609854 Since absolutely nobody is contributing, I figured that I would put my two cents, as to what I think some last minute changes should look like >Anon suggested Grim Dawn, a diablo clone working off the titan quest engine. I agree, it's a 2016 game, and would replace Dishonored 2 >I just remembered some anon suggested Katana Zero for 2019 pick, going as far as reserving it beforehand. Sorry about that, just gave it a look, I have no problem with it going on the list, but what game it would replace would be a better question. My pick would be Luigi's Mansion 3, since my understanding is that's not the best in the series >In a very embarrassing display of ignorance, nobody suggested UNDERRAIL. It is technically a 2012 game, since it went early access then, but there are too many good games that came out that year, so I am thinking it could be bumped up to it's "official" release date of 2015. The game I have not seen anyone really defending would be "Ori And The Blind Forest", which is part of the "Emotional Platformers" genre. I think Underrail deserves to be here much more >Lastly, looking at the GOTY releases back to back, I realized Valheim deserves the GOTY spot for 2021 much more than Deathloop. Problem is I didn't play Valheim, so I can't confirm this, but every look at the game more or less confirms it, and it is a very popular opinion online. I don't see any love for Deathloop here, so I am thinking of switching these two around I don't suppose anyone will reply at this point, but if I were to make these changes, would anyone have a problem with this? Are there any other thoughts on the current GOTY picks?

>>610090 Underrail absolutely positively needs a spot there wow anon nice catch. I don't know shit about deathloop can't help you with that one. Luigi's mansion 3 is just meh. Besides the original one was a big release title so I'm sure japs heard of it already.

>>610095 If underrail would replace Ori, it would be an "Honorable Mention", which I think it absolutely is not, it deserves better. The best game I can think of that would fit that title would be "Crypt of the Necrodancer", since while great, it is a niche little indie game, which suits a "personal recommendation" spot much more. Would there be a problem with this?

This is the new list, with the changes from above 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones And The Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Defense Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Myst <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Crash Bandicoot Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Quake 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Blood Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Warzone 2100 <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Halo: Combat Evolved* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Grand Theft Auto III Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Halo 2 <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Underrail <Just Cause 3 <Crypt of the Necrodancer <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Grim Dawn <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Risk of Rain 2* Noita Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Boneworks <Warsaw <Katana Zero <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Hades* Ultrakill Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Valheim* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Deathloop Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks I think it looks pretty good, and I can't think of any other GOTY picks that need to be changed. Is there anything I missed?

>>610097 Nectrodancer is a fucking footnote compared to the production value and mechanical complexity of underrail. Absolutely no objections from me.

The Core and Honorable mentions should have been switched around yesterday, but nobody was contributing. I noticed some titles could be turned around: >Modern Warfare 3. My logic(keeping in mind I made the initial list right before work, and didn't have too much time to think about it) was that MW2 was on the list, and MW3 is MW2+, so it also deserved a spot. Looking back, DR2: OTR is basically DR2+, but it has a honorable mentions, rather than a core spot. I want to correct that, and put MW3 on the Honorable Mentions, question is, what would take it's spot, inFamous 2 or Deus Ex? I have a bit of bias towards Human Revolution, as it is nothing like the original DE, and I have no experience with inFamous 2, some insight would be needed >I played Timesplitters 2 several times, at a friend's house, and we played, well, split screen multiplayer. Metroid Prime is a title I have more experience with, and I loved it. To those that played both, which do you think actually deserves to be on the Core Games spot more? >Is Perfect Dark good enough to be on the Core List spot, and if so, what could it replace? >For 1996, Duke or Quake? I have Bias towards Duke, but I want to hear some opinions. Also, is Civilization 2 worth moving over, and if so, what would it replace? >I heard some people saying that "TES Arena is overrated". Would Myst be a preferable alternative, if they were to switch spots? >This one is largely dependent on taste, should Sam & Max be on the Core List or Day of the Tentacle? I don't want to make these decisions myself, as I think the current spots already show my bias a bit too much.

>>610090 >>609855 you are a walking detriment codnigger, go fuck yourself

>>610138 good input, I will keep that in mind

>>610139 kill yourself

>>610140 >>610139 Now kiss

That's nice dumpster fire.

>>610148 >>610168 what do you think about >>610134 I think the list is in the final stages of completion, but these are kinda eating away at me

>>610134 My thoughts are to remove cod.

Even the early call of duty games were mindless.

>>610204 I made a case for each of the COD games on the list as to why they are there. I did remove one with a better game an anon suggested, tho. If you want a specific one gone, suggest a better title, but you will have to sell it to me. It will be easier to simply take those that are there and try and get them bumped down to "honorable mentions", like I suggested with MW3 >>610205 I actually previously voted for COD 1 and COD 2 to be there, but there were many other games that deserved to be in those years(2003 and 2005) much more, so I ended up removing them

>>610102 >Shilling COD games Fuck off Activision. >Halo 2 The only thing that was good about it was the multiplayer and that's dead. >Asscreed Was this list made by plebbitor? Or are you reading off this from some cuckhanner's /v/ recommendation? The game does stealth poorly and has one of the dumbest stories in gaming. It is literally just Templars bad, and historical revisionism. >Fallout 3 Nice try Todd. >Gaylo reach The most mediocre game within the series. >L.A Noire Overrated, and has poorly designed mechanics for it to be a proper detective game. >Far Cry 3 Lol no. >Max Payne 3 Not worth picking up if multiplayer is dead. >Payday 2 Is literal shit. >Arkham Origins The Batman games were never good. >Dead Rising 3 Obvious retard pick. >Shadow Of Mordor Asscreed, but with Lord Of the Rings. Does Stealth slightly better, but everything else is unappealing, considering you can still become a combat god. >Fallout4 Again, nice try Todd. >Witcher 3 I'll never understand how this game got so much praise for things it clearly wasn't. DLC was ok. >RDR2 Is pozzed, should be skipped for hand-holding gameplay and shit multiplayer. >Far Cry 5 Another extremely retarded pick. Next you'll say Far Cry 6. >Outerworlds Tries to be Fallout: New Vegas and fails in every single way. >Unironically recommending Cold War. Someone handle the list and take it away from this CODtard before he get Japs to become as mentally retarded as Amerifats. >I think it's good That's because you have shit taste.

>>610264 Do you actually have any better games to offer in their place? Keep in mind that multiple people suggested most of these games, not just me

>>610268 >Do you actually have any better games to offer in their place Remove the games I shat on and your list will be fine enough. Even though it needs some adjustments. A couple things you could include: Swat 4, Rollercoaster Tycoon 2, Terraria, Deus Ex GOTY, Red Alert 2, Dark Messiah Might and Magic.

>>610276 Sorry, but OP's stipulation is that EVERY YEAR needs x amount of games, hence why you see such garbage as assassin's creed or cold war on there. Personally, I would just do this by genres, not years, so there wouldn't be several COD games on there(this is the WORST type of list for them, as this is a yearly franchise), but I didn't make this thread >SWAT 4, Rollercoaster Tycoon 2, Deus Ex, Red Alert 2 Nigger, did you even read the list? They're all on there >Terraria, Dark Messiah I will see what year they're from, and see if they can replace something else. If you want something like Cold war replaced, find a game from that year that could take it's place. There is still 2 hours left to change the list

Terraria is a 2011 game, so it could easily replace COD MW3. Dark Messiah is a 2006 game, there is a lot of good titles for that year, but I know Todd isn't popular around here. Would anyone object if I removed TES IV for Dark Messiah?(I wanted to include that game, too, but I forgot about it when I made the list originally, work ect.)

Added these two titles, so this is how the list looks now 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones And The Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Defense Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Myst <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Crash Bandicoot Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Quake 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Blood Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Warzone 2100 <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Halo: Combat Evolved* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Grand Theft Auto III Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Halo 2 <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <Dark Messiah of Might and Magic <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl Assassin's Creed Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Terraria Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Far Cry 3 Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt* Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Underrail <Just Cause 3 <Crypt of the Necrodancer <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Grim Dawn <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Risk of Rain 2* Noita Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Boneworks <Warsaw <Katana Zero <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Hades* Ultrakill Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Valheim* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Deathloop Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks I still need your input on >>610134 and as Underrail was recently, and since some think Witcher 3 is overrated, would anyone object if I made Underrail GOTY for 2015?

>>610285 >OP's stipulation is that EVERY YEAR needs x amount of games So OP is basically retarded. >Nigger, did you even read the list? No, because I only read the list I've responded to you on and I don't feel like reading all the autism above. Let me give you a list, on the top of my head. I'll do the dates for you, but skip over anything that already on the list. >Disgaea (2003) >Disgaea 2 (2006) >Sengoku Rance (2006) >Sonic Robo Blast 2 (2011) >Gravity Rush (2012) >Gravity Rush 2 (2017) >SRB2Kart (2018?) >Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (2019) >Terraria is a 2011 game, so it could easily replace COD MW3. Replace it. >TES IV for Dark Messiah Yes, it is much more fun to play than TES IV.

>>610321 Sorry, but only western games are allowed >replace it already did Since nobody really is defending assassin's creed, I am looking into a replacement for it. 2007 is ripe with plenty of good games, I'm thinking something along the lines of >Orange Box(TF2 + Portal) >Crysis >Witcher What other good games came out that year? Also, is it alright to put Underrail as GOTY for 2015? Reminder that there is only one hour left, so I need any potential changes/input quickly

>>610334 Reminder, choosing ends by the end of the hour, as I have things to do. If nobody will suggest anything better, I will replace Assassin's Creed with The Witcher, as it fits thematically(historical stealth game vs fantasy rpg) Underrail shouldn't really be contested, and it isn't, so I will award it the GOTY pick for 2015, putting Witcher 3 in the Core Games Category I've also noticed Far Cry 3 isn't popular. For 2012, here are some good selections I can think of >Hotline Miami >SCP: Containment Breach >Sleeping Dogs >Need for Speed: Most Wanted Keeping in theme with similar games, Sleeping Dogs is also an open world game, so unless anybody objects, I could also replace Far Cry 3 with it

>>610354 Taking these final additions into account, here is how the FINAL final list looks 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones And The Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Defense Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Myst <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Crash Bandicoot Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Quake 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Blood Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Warzone 2100 <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Halo: Combat Evolved* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Grand Theft Auto III Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Halo 2 <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <Dark Messiah of Might and Magic <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl The Witcher Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Terraria Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Sleeping Dogs Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >Underrail Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt <Just Cause 3 <Crypt of the Necrodancer <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Grim Dawn <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Risk of Rain 2* Noita Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Boneworks <Warsaw <Katana Zero <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Hades* Ultrakill Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Valheim* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Deathloop Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks I took all the input I could, but sadly, not as many anons as I had hoped would contribute. I said at the beginning of the weekend that I would close the list off permanently, and I mean it. I aim to get this into an actual chart in the near future. If you have any final suggestions, you have until I come back from wagecucking and look into this thread again, but if it's not a solid choice, from a game that universally deserves to be on the list, but somehow got missed, prepare for it to be thrown out. No more indies only literally one person played. That said, as to how the chart is going to be made, >>608861 This anon actually got started on working on the template for the list, including basic layout, flags and other little icons, as well as getting info for these games(I did a fair portion, too, as seen in >>609260) As you can see, the agreement was that two lists would be made, this one(the first), and later, one made by OP, if he chose to "finish" it, which I doubt he would. That said, since this one is complete, there is no need to not make this one, and simply edit it once the layout is finished, to make the other list as well, editing in or out entries not on the first list(this one) later. This was agreed upon by both parties, with no subterfuge or tomfoolery from either parties involved. That said, he has been MIA for some time, so he's either busy, or changed his mind. Either way, I got my own plans, so the list is gonna be made one way, or the other, with or without his help, altho he does seem talented, so it would be a shame if he quit now. That said, like I mentioned, if you have some very final suggestions for the list, make them now, and make them good, as by the time I will come back, and start contacting people who might help me, it the list needs to be 100% finalized Lastly, I would like to thank everyone who actually gave input as for what should be on this list, not just now, but over the several last threads, as those choices were the foundation for this one. I hope everyone is as happy with the final result as I am, but if you're not, well, the weekend was all yours to make the changes. The weekend is now over

>>610388 It was actually really fun, as it was both a memory lane and added some games on my backlog. That said, I do wish OP set some less retarded stipulations at the start, and that others would contribute more, I did everything I could with what I was given, especially considering the last thread DIED because of him Anyways, I am going to go to sleep, as I do need to go to work soon. Then, when I do come back, I will take one final look at the list, and assuming the Graphic Designer anon is still MIA or changed his mind, start figuring out how this list is actually going to be made.

So, now that the CoDnigger is done and gone, let's see about getting this thread back on track. Here is a reposting of the sample list for 2019-2021 games, so that the original list, back up here, can be finished: >>608838 2019 >Boneworks A first-person physics based action game >Call of Duty: Modern Warfare >Chernobylite >Control >Gato Roboto A open-world side-scrolling run and gun game >Indivisible >Into the Radius VR A survival FPS >Katana Zero >Noita >Outer Wilds A space exploration simulator that loops every 20 minutes >Risk of Rain 2 A survival-based rogue-like 3D platformer with multiplayer >Shantae and the Seven Sirens >The Outer Worlds >Warsaw >Yooka-Laylee and the Impossible Lair 2020 >Call of Duty: Black Ops - Cold War >Carrion A side-scrolling evolution game where the player becomes an ever-increasingly larger monster >Cyber Hook >Dreams >Ghost of Tsushima An open-world RPG with stealth elements >Ghostrunner >Half-Life: Alyx >Helltaker >Hylics 2 An isometric turn-based RPG with exploration elements >Iron Harvest >Mount and Blade Bannerlord An open-world medieval RPG with hack & slash and strategy elements >Ori and the Will of the Wisps >Project Wingman A flight combat simulator >Serious Sam 4 >Streets of Rage 4 >Ultrakill A first-person character action games focusing on the usage of guns >Wasteland 3 2021 >Aeterna Noctis A side-scrolling open-world 2D beat 'em up >Aliens: Fireteam Elite >Axiom Verge 2 >Biomutant >Deathloop >Death's Door >Evil Genius 2 >Ghostrunner A first-person hack & slash with platforming elements >Inscryption >Intravenous A top-down stealth based shooter based upon clearing each level of enemies >It takes two A cooperative full 3D puzzle platformer >Kaze and the Wild Masks >Madness Nexus Project A top-down twin stick shooter >Necromunda: Hired Gun >Sable >Stronghold: Warlords

>>610386 I don't see the response from the person who claimed he would help in designing the chart, nor do I see any input from anybody else, so I am considering this list finished. I will be contacting a few people, and seeing about putting some prototypes in MS Paint, maybe as early as tomorrow or wednesday >>610593 The list is already finished, and nobody cares what you have to say. You should thank me I did your job for you, even with your asinine requirements nobody seemed to like

Bumping this up so that we can finish this list off soon. Again, remaining years that still need to be decided are listed here: >>610593

Where is the latest list image?

>>616459 The person who was originally going to do it seemingly gave up on it, so I am doing it instead, as I said >>610386 here It's going to be a rough draft, I am still actually thinking how the layout is going to look. It might seem simple, but if you want to make a change while you're halfway thru, it is a major pain in the ass, so I am already asking these questions. Once the rough draft is done, I will outline what else needs to be done, and see about doing just that, if the actual graphic work turns out to be too much of a hassle, I might just contract someone else to do that part

>>616459 >Where is the latest list image? As far as the image, it hasn't been made yet because we're still compiling the list. <The closest that we have as far as an idea is this mock-up that was made by one Anon. The list so far comprises of this list: >>608838 And we're still in the process of trying to compile a list for 2019-2021, as you can see here: >>610593 HOWEVER, it appears that the thread now exists in a state of limbo because the CoDnigger spammed the threads demanding that every CoD entry in the series be submitted as the "best of" for it's respective years (With accompanying rants), completely rewrote the list that people had originally agreed to, ignores the fact that no one agrees with him and wants him gone, and is SUPPOSE to have fucked off by now as he "finished" his own version of the list last week and is suppose to be publishing a final version of it for the entire world to see.

>>616662 I think for posterity's sake, only the first Call of Duty should be included in this list. It's not a bad game and came before Modern Warfare/Call of Duty 4 which introduced the casual shooter mechanics to the world. No CoDs added to the list besides that. Should be a good compromise.

>>616667 That's the thing, though. Anons didn't have a problem with the original, nor later titles like COD4:MW and W@W. However, the fag kept demanding that every CoD be listed every year each respective game released. All the way up through BLOPS Cold War. In fact, he's still putting them in his own list, which you can see here: >>610386

>>616675 If you asked /v/ ten years ago, they'd all shit on Halo CE and Modern Warfare and World at War. I think we should maintain the same zeitgeist as them despite the recent influx of people born after 2000 who are now using imageboards.

>>616679 >I think we should maintain the same zeitgeist as them despite the recent influx of people born after 2000 who are now using imageboards. That's a little hard because I remember even oldfags from when I first showed up stating that the last "good" CoD was W@W (MW I can understand why it's not enjoyed as even I don't like it). Halo, though, I've always been confused about because it doesn't play like a traditional shooter (Which comes down more to taste than quality), and much of the hate seemed directed towards the companies who were "inspired" by it rather than the quality of the game itself.

>>616685 Remember the point of this thread and the chart. Recommending games of guaranteed quality. If you exhibit even a bit of reluctance to include a game like Halo or W@W, then it's proof it doesn't belong on the list. Maybe it's best not to restrict ourselves to 5 games per year if maybe that one year didn't release that many strong games. I've seen too many years listed ITT where maybe one or two classics are picked for a year but clearly the other 3 are just shots in the dark where even the person who recommended the game probably hasnt played it or feels as strong about it as they would a "classic" per se. We do not want to mislead our Japanese friends, do we?

may i suggest we get some input from the recent hispachan arrivals?

>>610593 Ok anon, im gonna only suggest the ones ive played. 2019 >noita >katana zeto 2020 >bannerlord >ultrakill >project wingman >ghost runner I played and liked alyx but i cant on good consciense recommend a VR game so few people can play. 2021 >Intravenous >Necromunda: Hired Gun

What the hell happened here?

>>617266 So, there's a start for those years. >>618802 Rapefugee's can't help but NOT be spergs.

Why would you shill CoD of all things?

>>618805 Implying that native anons don't also sperg.

>>618817 >Why would you shill CoD of all things? For some "people", that's all the reference they have. It's incredibly sad.

>>618849 "Persona 5 vibes!" -Youtube commenters

>>617266 I know it's a mod but it's pretty quality. Ashes Afterglow can go in for 2021.

>>608679 >disco elysium >amogus >deathloop this has got to be an out of season april fools joke

>>618897 Do you not have phones?

>>618897 Do you forget the image of the "official" h8chan Steam group all playing MW2 and Fallout 4 on launch day?

>>619741 >all playing <when it wasn't even a full page out of several pages of members Go back to your pit, /cow/.

>>619741 >steam group >official Anyways I see no issues with playing MW2 (well paying for it is cancer, thats a fair poin) , FO4 is a different story due to the Boston salt party, that's a disgrace

I'm still making a list and checking it twice, and when I did, I noticed that we have an EXTRA SPOT FOR THE HONORABLE MENTIONS LIST Last time I asked for feedback, I found that this board is mostly dead, and had little participation. This is how the list currently looks >>610386 I don't want to actually add any myself, but if people actually put down some games for every year aside from 2018(I have something planned for it), I can add them to the list, and the chart that will be made. Otherwise, I will keep it to the standard 3 for Honorable Mentions. AGAIN, THIS WILL ONLY BE CONSIDERED IF PEOPLE PARTICIPATE As for the chart itself, I am almost done working out all the graphic design kinks, and should be able to get the rough draft done soon, to be posted here >>618817 >What happened here Autism, same as every other day >Why COD of all things? Japan is the second most popular region for COD games outside of North America, so I don't see why this would be an issue. This is a list for them, after all, not for the average user here. Also, the "rules" set at the very start said that we have to count the games on YEARLY bases, and COD is a yearly franchise, giving it a boost. I doubt we would see too many of them, if we simply did the smart thing and divided games by genres and not years. That was not my call to make, tho >>618897 yes Also, I made that list very quickly, and it was hard to get something for later years. That's why I also think doing this list based on years was a mistake. Deathloop wasn't bad, tho, and nobody suggested anything better, leading me to believe nobody actually played anything released in 2021, or at least not anything that could be added to the list. I heard good things about disco elysium, but people here said they didn't like it, so I removed it

>>623590 Anon, we fucking told you before, theres no fucking point in making the list for 2021, much less 2022, even the games we played and liked are not "game of the year" material, fucking accept it already.

>>616667 >No CoDs added to the list besides that UO had better multiplayer but that's probably not something nips care about and is long since dead. Everything 2 and onwards, after the series went multiplat, is just a gradual decline.

>>623592 The list only extends to 2021, not 2022. I think most people agreed on the GOTY choices, at least, I think Hades and Valheim are still good choices, even if not as impactful as earlier games. Signs of changing times, but in doing research, I did manage to find some decent titles. Be the change you want, there has to be at least one good game even for the recent years

>>623603 >Be the change you want How you dense cunt? I cannot make the games better.

>>623605 Suggest a game for every year from 1992 to 2021, other than 2018. There are plenty in the earlier years, I bet there are a few for later years as well. If you can't think of any, skip those years I know I missed out on quite a few good games, due to the 8 game per year limit, so now is the chance to get them back in there. I don't want to be involved, tho, so if nobody participates, I guess I will stick to what I already have >>623595 There is plenty to love about even recent COD games, I think people only think they are composed of the campaign and multiplayer modes when the third mode(usually zombies) is where the real meat of the game is. If the list wasn't yearly, tho, I doubt I would suggest as many of them as I did

>>623606 >Suggest a game for every year from 1992 to 2021, other than 2018 I already did you cunt, ive been in this list from the start.

>>623607 Yeah, and this list has been going forever, lately with no activity, so I might have forgotten. One anon suggested Katana Zero, for example, and I forgot about it until the eleventh hour, with all that's going on, but I included it nevertheless. If that's the case, would you kindly run what you suggested per year again for me? Again, it has to be something that's not already in this post >>623590

I said I wouldn't get involved, but there was one title I wanted in, but it was in contention due to the year it released(early access, 2013) I guess that will be my pick for that year, unless someone actually does go, year by year, to add anything of their own

>>623608 >If that's the case, would you kindly run what you suggested per year again for me? Did you seriusly lose the votes?

>>623614 Do you still remember what you suggested? It shouldn't be too hard to remember, if you actually liked these games. I am only looking for one title per year, the rest have been decided

>>623616 Allright then. >1992 Dune 2. >1993 Doom >1994 System shock. >1995 MK3 >1996 civ 2 >1997 Fallout >1998 Half-life >1999 Jagged alliance 2 >2000 Deus ex >2001 Max payne >2002 Vice city >2003 KOTOR >2004 Dawn of war >2005 FEAR >2006 Dark messiah >2007 Halo 3 >2008 Dead space >2009 L4D2 >2010 New vegas >2011 MK9 >2012 nuXcom >2013 Risk of rain >2014 Alien isolation >2015 Dying light >2016 Superhot >2017 Cuphead >2018 KCD >2019 Katana zero >2020 hades

Anon, I think every single one of those games is already on the list, other than dawn of war for 2004 please see >>610386 for details. select one other game per year that is NOT on it also, you suggested Necromunda for 2021, mind if I keep that for that year? I doubt we will get anything else for it

>>623621 >>623619

>>623622 >>623621 Oh shit i forgot it was honorable mentions.

For reference, here's the current make-up of the list for 2019-2021: >2019 <Katana Zero <Noita >2020 <Ghostrunner <Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord <Project Wingman <Ultrakill >2021 <Ashes (Mod) <Intravenous <Necromunda: Hired Gun Still need to populate the list with more games. Examples of the games that released those years can be found here: >>610593

>>623666 >2021:Ashes Ashes Afterglow. Because it's a sequel to Ashes 2063.

I'm glad Cuphead is on the list. What a masterpiece of a game. And it gave us the best game journalist meme to exist. That video is a piece of surrealist art.

Oh yeah for 2016 I'd definitely suggest Rabi Ribi.

>>623683 >I'd definitely suggest Rabi Ribi. That's a Taiwanese games. Also, 2016 has already been done.

>>623690 >It's taiwanese Huh, never knew that. For some reason I thought it was brazilian.

>>623693 That's understandable considering how they make games like Fight'N Rage and Long Gone Days.

>>617266 >Bannerlord I don't want to put games that haven't been released yet. However, original Mount and Blade has been released in 2008, so it could go in that year's spot >UltraKill Already on the list >Ghostrunner Already there >Project Wingman I guess that could be alright, there is no decent combat flight sims on the list, anyhow HERE IS HOW THE LAST HONORABLE MENTIONS SPOT LOOKS RIGHT NOW 1992- 1993- 1994- 1995- 1996- 1997- 1998- 1999- 2000- 2001- 2002- 2003- 2004-Warhammer 40k: Dawn of War 2005- 2006- 2007- 2008-Mount & Blade 2009- 2010- 2011- 2012- 2013-Kenshi 2014- 2015- 2016- 2017- 2019- 2020-Project Wingman 2021-Necromunda: Hired Gun The years with blanks have one more vacant spot, due to how the chart is being designed. See >>623621 For a list of games already there. Do keep in mind it has to be a game released by WESTERN devs, you also don't have to go thru the years, checking them off, if you have a few select titles to suggest, that's fine, just name off the year it's from.

>>623703 >combat flight sims Project Wingman is heavily inspired by Ace Combat, anon.

>>623705 yeah, which is a japanese franchise. This is the WESTERN GAME thread If you have any games you want to see added(that are not already on the list), list them. There are way too many to add and keep everybody satisfied, so I am glad we get at least one more go

>>623706 Project Wingman is a western game though.

>>623703 >2019 Blasphemous >2018 Mecanicus

>>623710 >Blasphemous sure thing >Mecanicus Sorry, I got something planned for 2018, as it stands. However, if you want to replace any of the current 2018 games on the list for it, be my guess, just name which one you thinks deserves the spot better. That year was really iffy, for some reason: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance*(GOTY) World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy(these are honorable mentions) <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury

>>623703 >>623706 >>623714 Fuck OFF CODNIGGER!

Crash N sane trilogy for 2017.

>>623718 No problem If you got a whole list, write off the rest in one big post. I'm gonna go on my noon jog right now, so I won't be here for a bit anyhow

Where is the list, if I may make some suggestions

>>623727 see >>610386 I don't want to keep linking to it, tho. What's here has already been decided, but I am looking for one extra game for the year, due to the layout of the chart allowing us to do as such

>>623729 *for every year, I mean

It has to be one of the pink ones? I'll just throw some oddballs >2003: Postal 2 >2012: Lone Survivor >2015: Lisa The Painful >2018: Fear and Hunger >2020: Post Void >2021: Cruelty Squad I don't get it, sorry I am autistic, good luck

>>623732 Postal 2 is already on the list. There is plenty of good games for that year, tho For 2020 and 2021, I guess we would have to decide which to keep, as there were already some suggestions >>623703

>>623727 >Where is the list, if I may make some suggestions This is the list: of what we have so far for all of the years completed: >>608838 These are the years that we are focusing on: >>610593 And, this is the current list that we have for those years: >>623666 The rest of the lists you see posted in this thread is a personal list created by some CoD autist who started sperging in the previous thread about how every CoD game is the greatest game every year it released, only to then completely rewrite the list that was being compiled because he wasn't happy with how his suggestions were being received: https://archive.ph/js5gA#607989

So far, we got: 1992- 1993- 1994- 1995- 1996- 1997- 1998- 1999- 2000- 2001- 2002- 2003- 2004-Warhammer 40k: Dawn of War 2005- 2006- 2007- 2008-Mount & Blade 2009- 2010- 2011- 2012-Lone Survivor 2013-Kenshi 2014-Lisa: The Painful 2015- 2016- 2017-Crash N Sane Trilogy 2019-Blasphemous 2020-Project Wingman, Post Void 2021-Necromunda: Hired Gun, Cruelty Squad Blank spots need to be filled in, if there are more games than one for that year(like in 2020 and 2021, currently), it will need a tie breaker. So far, so good

>>623775 If we're going to keep N Sane Trilogy, then we got the same problem we originally had with Spyro games: Namely, that there were the originals, and then a re-release that is just HD ports of said games. With Spyro, it was more justified, as the japanese Spyro games, for some baffling reason, were fucking awful, rest of the releases were fine I need a Crash expert here, does the N Sane trilogy fuck up the original Bandicoot game, and if not, does the original deserve to be on the list if it goes thru? I don't remember any controversies about the japanese port of the game, so I assume nothing horrible happened to it If this was the case, we would have a vacant 1996 spot as well for the main list

>>623919 >IMO re-releases don't count unless they have quality of life improvements or can be modded easily. The only rerelease that we had was for the Spyro Reignited Trilogy due to the how broken the original game was when it released in Japan on the PS1 and how the third game never made it overseas. As for the N Sane Trilogy, they're inferior remakes, and pointless since the Crash games are already listed on here: >>608838 And, here (If there's room for honorable mentions): >>608738

>>623727 >>623732 don't interact with codnigger the list is >>623666

>>623666 For 2019, I've heard good things about Risk of Rain 2 and Outer Wilds from some friends, but I haven't played them myself. Can vouch for Project Wingman. I'd love to flesh the later years out but I've played fuck-all recent games also fuck The Outer Worlds and Indivisible

Update on 2019-2021: >2019 <Boneworks <Katana Zero <Later Alligator <Noita <Risk of Rain 2 <Yuppie Psycho >2020 <Ghost of Tsushima <Ghostrunner <Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord <Project Wingman <Streets of Rage 4 <Ultrakill >2021 <Ashes Afterglow (Mod) <Intravenous <It Takes Two <Kaze and the Wild Masks <Necromunda: Hired Gun <Snoot Game Referred the past threads because I just remembered that some other Anons had recommended some good games. As of right now. There are six games for each year, which one do you guys think should be the odd one out for these years to be later listed as an "Honorable mention" if we have the space?

dragon age origins belongs on this list

>>624437 >>625012 Keeping this in mind, this is what we have as of now for the last round of honorable mentions: 1992- 1993- 1994- 1995- 1996- 1997- 1998- 1999- 2000- 2001- 2002- 2003- 2004-Warhammer 40k: Dawn of War 2005- 2006- 2007- 2008-Mount & Blade 2009-Dragon Age Origins 2010- 2011- 2012-Lone Survivor 2013-Kenshi 2014-Lisa: The Painful 2015- 2016- 2017-Crash N Sane Trilogy 2019-Blasphemous 2020-Project Wingman 2021-Necromunda: Hired Gun or Cruelty Squad I haven't seen anyone else participate, so I filled in the remaining years with what I think should definitely be on the list, but landed up on the cutting room floor due to lack of spots. I would normally choose several picks and have discussions about which one belongs here the most, but clearly that's not going to happen, so here is how the last batch will look, unless anyone has a problem with it: 1992-Prince of Persia(Macintosh and Super Nintendo ports, which are seen as some of the best overall) 1993-Alladin(Sega Megadrive version) 1994-Killer Instinct 1995-Wipeout 1996-Broken Sword: Shadow of Templars 1997-Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee 1998-Banjo Kazooie 1999-Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver 2000-MDK 2 2001-IL-2 Sturmovik 2002-Mafia 2003-Manhunt 2004-Warhammer 40k: Dawn of War 2005-Oddworld: Stranger's Wrath 2006-Just Cause 2007-Overlord 2008-Mount & Blade 2009-Dragon Age Origins 2010-Alan Wake 2011-Ghost Recon: Shadow Wars 2012-Lone Survivor 2013-Kenshi 2014-Lisa: The Painful 2015-Zombie Army Trilogy 2016-Doom(2016) 2017-Crash N Sane Trilogy 2019-Blasphemous 2020-Project Wingman 2021-Necromunda: Hired Gun or Cruelty Squad For the record, if nobody vouches for Cruelty Squad, I will take Necromunda over it, since the former seems like a meme game that plays decently by accident, plus the latter was suggested first. I'm very much ready to actually start putting the rough draft together, so I will give this a day or two to settle in, if nobody participates(again), I will just use this for the chart. I realize that it's impossible to fit all the great games that came out in some of those years, even with 9 slots instead of 8, but I think this, for the most part, should satisfy everybody. If you disagree, tell me which game deserves to be here more, and what year it came out. For reference, this is the final list, the games seen above will be added to each individual year as "Personal Recommendations", or as red text seen here. We're about done, so unless anyone else has anything to add, this is a done deal: 1992: >Ultima VII* Alone in the Dark Mortal Kombat Indiana Jones And The Fate of Atlantis Dune II <Wolfenstein 3D <Darkseed <Flashback 1993: >Doom* Star Fox Sim City 2000 Sam & Max Hit The Road NBA Jam <Cannon Fodder <Day of The Tentacle <Duke Nukem II 1994: >System Shock* Donkey Kong Country X-Com: UFO Defense Doom II The Elder Scrolls: Arena <Mega Turrican <Myst <Star Wars: TIE Fighter 1995: >Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn* Warcraft II Rayman Descent Twisted Metal <Earthworm Jim 2 <Donkey Kong Country 2 <Mortal Kombat 3 1996: >Duke Nukem 3D* The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Crash Bandicoot Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Tomb Raider <Descent II <Civilization II <Quake 1997: >Fallout* Goldeneye 007 Carmageddon Blood Tomb Raider II <Turok: Dinosaur Hunter <Tetrisphere <Grand Theft Auto 1998: >Half Life* Fallout 2 Starcraft Thief: The Dark Project Grim Fandango <Rainbow Six <Baldur's Gate <Need For Speed III: Hot Pursuit 1999: >Quake 3: Arena* Rayman 2 Jagged Alliance 2 Donkey Kong 64 Planscape Torment <Warzone 2100 <Driver <Freespace 2 2000: >Diablo II* Baldur's Gate 2 Deus Ex Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 <Colin McRae Rally 2.0 <Indiana Jones And The Infernal Machine <Perfect Dark 2001: >Halo: Combat Evolved* Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura Grand Theft Auto III Max Payne Serious Sam: The First Encounter <Ghost Recon <Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 <Conker's Bad Fur Day 2002: >The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind* Battlefield 1942 GTA Vice City Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Metroid Prime <Timesplitters 2 <Bloodrayne <Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 2003: >Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic* Rayman 3 Max Payne 2: Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX 3 <Sim City 4 <Postal 2 <Rainbow Six: Raven Shield 2004: >Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas* Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates! Half Life 2 Halo 2 <Unreal Tournament 2004 <Painkiller <Metroid Prime 2 2005: >F.E.A.R* Need For Speed: Most Wanted Psychonauts Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Battlefield 2 <SWAT 4 <Burnout Revenge <Super Mario Strikers 2006: >Trackmania Nations* Rainbow Six: Vegas Prey Hitman: Blood Money Tomb Raider: Legend <Dark Messiah of Might and Magic <Marvel: Ultimate Alliance <Alien Shooter: Vengeance 2007: >Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare* Bioshock STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl The Witcher Halo 3 <Lego Starwars: Complete Saga <Quake Wars: Enemy Territory <Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 2008: >Grand Theft Auto IV* Fallout 3 Call of Duty: World At War Dead Space Saints Row 2 <Iron Man: The Game <Star Wars: The Force Unleashed <Spelunky 2009: >Left 4 Dead 2* Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Halo Wars Batman: Arkham Asylum inFamous <Skate 2 <X-Men Origins: Wolverine <Killing Floor 2010: >Fallout: New Vegas* Read Dead Redemption Dead Rising 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops Halo: Reach <Civilization V <Bioshock 2 <Metro 2033 2011: >Mortal Kombat(2011)* Terraria Serious Sam 3: BFE Dead Space 2 L.A Noire <inFamous 2 <Deus Ex: Human Revolution <Dead Rising 2: Off The Record 2012: >Spec Ops: The Line* Sleeping Dogs Max Payne 3 Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 XCOM: Enemy Unknown <Darksiders II <Katawa Shoujo <Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed 2013: >Grand Theft Auto V* Payday 2 Call of Duty Ghosts Batman: Arkham Origins Dead Rising 3 <Battleblock Theater <Risk of Rain <Rayman Legends 2014: >Alien: Isolation* The Crew South Park: The Stick of Truth Wasteland 2 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor <Trials Fusion <Child of Light <Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare 2015: >Underrail Fallout 4 Hotline Miami 2 Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt <Just Cause 3 <Crypt of the Necrodancer <Dying Light 2016: >Stardew Valley* Superhot Call of Duty Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Grim Dawn <XCOM 2 <Titanfall 2 <Factorio 2017: >A Hat in Time* Cuphead Halo Wars 2 Hollow Knight Prey(2017) <Sonic Mania <Alien Shooter: TD <South Park: Fractured But Whole 2018: >Kingdom Come: Deliverance* World War 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 Far Cry 5 Hitman 2 <Spyro: Reignited Trilogy <Pathfinder: Kingmaker <Ion Fury 2019: >Risk of Rain 2* Noita Call of Duty: Modern Warfare(2019) Outer Worlds Boneworks <Warsaw <Katana Zero <The Outer Wilds 2020: >Hades* Ultrakill Wasteland 3 Ghostrunner Microsoft Flight Simulator(2020) <Iron Harvest <Black Mesa <Call of Duty: Cold War 2021: >Valheim* Chernobylite Aliens: Fireteam Elite Deathloop Hitman 3 <Rainbow Six: Extraction <F1 2021 <Kaze and the Wild Masks

>>626419 CoDnigger, fuck off.

Come on, Anons, we're so damn close to finishing the list for the Nips! All that's primarily left is to weed out the games that shouldn't be considered the best for 2019-2021: >>624918

>>630089 I really like this image. The Three Cabaleros (calabreros?) are some of the absolute best stories about Donald. I actually met Don Rosa a few years ago at a convention and told him that, how much I enjoyed Donald getting into the action in those stories with two real friends at his side.

Is nuclear throne on the list?

>>630250 No, no one ever submitted it.

>>630089 What a cute pic Anyhow, although not my favorite game, I'd vote for Crash Bandicoot 4: It's About Time as it's at least a passable western game.

I see no mention of Brigador in here. Add that to the list niggers. The SNC needs more pilots.

>>630492 >turn Tawna into a sjw dyke >passable I hope you become one of the 50% of your kind that kills yourselves.

>>630576 >the whore who cucked crash >not already a SJW dyke The game was rigged from the start.

>>630576 Imagine getting pissed off at the art direction instead of the gameplay Anyhow here this fixes it a bit https://gamebanana.com/mods/285354 >>630682 No like I get what he means I just don't get how someone would get so irrationally buttblasted by that and only that and not by some major gameplay issues.

>>630160 >Don Rosa Disney deserves all the cancer for how they treated him. Definitely the best Donald Duck cartoonist.

>>630160 What did he reply? Do you have an autograph? >>630999 I have a very old almanac containing the entirety of his first stories, it's a shame the pages are kind of crusty from how old it is.

>>631001 >What did he reply? I belive he said that Caballeros were his favorite stories too. It was a long line behind me, so we couldn't talk for long. I did leave with some of his homegrown peppers. Stuffed them in an omelette with mushroom and bacon. Tasty. >Do you have an autograph? I have TWO! He misspelled my name on the first one, so it was redone and gave me a second. One hangs above my computer, the other over my bed, both framed.

>>630995 Definitely but it's far easier to point at Out of Time's Tawna instead of going through why the game fundamentally sucks shit from how the art style makes noticing crates a challenge because they don't pop out from their backgrounds, a massive reliance of "ha-ha you didn't notice 4/5 out of view crates in this stage! Replay the fucking level buddy", complete lack of slidejump momentum, being too focused on incremental, kind of grindy level progression/completionism where actually getting all the crates(putting aside the heavy reliance on out of view crates) isn't a fun puzzle that adds to challenge but just a tedious slog. The game is like those four crates you had to run backwards to destroy in one of Crash 2's ice levels, that philosophy stretched into a whole game and that's just not fun.

>>630995 Why not use this Tawna mod instead? https://www.nexusmods.com/crashbandicoot4itsabouttime/mods/102

>>633186 that looks weird tbh, not feeling it

>>630995 >Imagine getting pissed off at the art direction instead of the gameplay I didn't say I wasn't pissed off at the gameplay, but what they did to Tawna is a perfect microcosm of their entire philosophy. They didn't like the original games, and made a sequel bad on purpose, since they didn't like the good ones. Their priorities were not only misplaced, going out of their way to push propaganda instead of putting all of their effort toward making a good game, but they were also deliberately trying to ruin what was already good, out of spite. It just so happens that Tawna is a perfect visual representation of that, a perfect example of how a picture is worth a thousand words. >>633186 Mods won't fix it because the game was made from the ground up to be bad on purpose, and putting a skin suit of old Tawna over new Tawna won't actually make her the old character. It's still the same SJW, acting like the same SJW, in a game designed around that SJW. Skinning the old one like Buffalo Bill won't fix that.

>>633453 Sounds like you're just bad at platforming in general. :^)

I took the liberty of going over every game currently on the list, either by playing it directly or at least looking up details on them. That said, I made some changes, listed below, new games taking their place based off choices already made several threads ago by others. For reference, this is the list referenced >>626419 Tell me if you disagree with those changes, keeping in mind replacements were all chosen by (you) already. I checked them over as well, so unless you have a last minute suggestion over them I don't see the games changing in any way(and I will not be editing the years I already have done at the moment, going by oldest to newest) That said, the actual layout of the chart is 100% taken care of and I have begun actually putting it together, but I am a one man operation. Now that I am confident in every title, I can take more time to putting everything together, and once I have a rough draft done, I will post it here, I very much intend to actually make it look nice and polished at the end even if it means hiring someone to help me out with it Here are the changes themselves: 1992-Prince of Persia for Super Star Wars, Mac port is considered one of the best, but game is too similar to Flashback. Lots of people here liked Super Star Wars, and it was a more arcade platformer to round up the rather adventure game dominated year 1994-Both TES Arena and TES II Daggerfall are free to download, and Bethesda games have...not changed much. While Arena is innovative and should be applauded for it, the game isn't fun to play for the same reason as modern Bethesda games are: Bugs, Poor Gameplay, Bad Worldbuilding, No Game Direction. Daggerfall itself is fine, replaced Arena with Earthworm Jim 1, for the same reason as Super Star Wars: Popular and got great arcade action 1996-Crash Bandicoot, similarly to Spyro: Reignited Trilogy, already has a remastered compilation, and there really isn't anything too special about the first game when you can play all 3 at once. Replaced it with Twisted Metal 2, altho Killer Instinct 2 was also a strong contender, but lost out due to lack of accesibility(Arcade exclusive until XBONE release) 1999-Changed Donkey Kong 64 to Age of Empires 2. While there is nothing wrong with it, it's too similar to Banjo Kazooie, and it feels silly to leave out AoE2 for that reason. Replaced Driver with System Shock 2 as well for the same reason, I still recommend it but the two aren't quite on the same level, SS2 being a genre defining classic with Driver simply being a fun little title, that used to rule it's "genre" until GTA 3 showed up a couple of years later. Bumped up System Shock 2 to GOTY spot, Quake 3 is now in "Honorable Mentions", but that doesn't really mean much as I removed the emphasis on the caste system, so unless you're a GOTY the main difference is being in either the first or the second row now 2000-Indiana Jones: Infernal Machine was actually a 1999 game, and despite it being a very competent Tomb Raider clone, there really wasn't anymore space for the game in that year. Replaced it with American McGee's Alice, another combat platformer 2008-As an Iron Man fan, I must admit I still enjoy the 2008 game("last gen" release, meaning PC/PS2/PSP and Wii, most people remember the awful 360 and PS3 variation). Going back to play the PC release recently, I have to admit that if you're not an Iron Man fan, or even haven't watched the movie the game is based off of, you're not going to find much to like here. I was hoping this would be something of a spider man 2 case, where you can enjoy it for what it is even if you're not fan of the comics or the movie, but I also have to be pragmatic about this. Replaced it with Audiosurf, which I wanted to put initially anyways 2010-Alan Wake was not as fun as I remember it being on replay. Not really sure what it was exactly, but I don't feel it belongs here. Replaced it with the first Darksiders 2011-LA Noire is a bit too rough around the edges to recommend. It had some really bad writing, and too many instances where things didn't make sense, I can excuse a few stupid puzzles or story hiccups in those adventures games but it felt like there was too much of that here. On the other hand, Hotline Miami keeps it nice and simple, and the second game is already on the list. 2012-Same story as with Alan Wake, X-Com simply wasn't as good as I remember it. As I played the original and the reboot back to back, the difference is jarring, the game is way too simplified to be called a strategy game anymore. Disappointing, I remember liking it back in the day. Replaced it with Dust: An Elysian Tail 2015-Not as much of a change, as there were two games contesting for the last spot: Zombie Army Trilogy and Brigador. I choose the latter for the list, as it has more content and more polished gameplay, but I also recommend the former as it is a competent RE4 clone with 4 player coop 2016-XCOM 2, similar reasons as XCOM: Enemy Unknown, sequel isn't different enough and you already know what I think about the previous game. Out of all the games suggested for 2016 in the previous thread, I found Redout the most fitting for it's spot, as it is a spiritual successor to Wipeout, but if you think I'm wrong, tell me.

Ignore and filter the CoDnigger Once again, need help finishing off the list for the years of 2019-2021: >2019 <Boneworks <Katana Zero <Later Alligator <Noita <Risk of Rain 2 <Yuppie Psycho >2020 <Ghost of Tsushima <Ghostrunner <Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord <Project Wingman <Streets of Rage 4 <Ultrakill >2021 <Ashes Afterglow (Mod) <Intravenous <It Takes Two <Kaze and the Wild Masks <Necromunda: Hired Gun <Snoot Game Because of the suggestions other Anons have made, there is currently six games for each of those years, and just need feedback on the odd-one out that should be out. Or, if there should be any other games added to expand to list of the potential five to be considered.

>>634398 <Snoot Game Was this actually a good game, or is it just a meme like Katawa Shoujo and Bernd?

>>634611 I've seen a lot of people liking it, and cuckchan moderation hating it so I would say give it a go

>>634398 >>642740 Maybe take out boneworks because its a VR game and barely anyone has a VR headset? Then ultrakill because ghostrunner is kind of similar but better, and snoot game please.

>>642745 > snoot game please You make a good point, I was thinking about how Hitman 3 is a bit samey when compared to Hitman 2, so I am going to update that Speaking of which, he's already working on another game, so I am looking forward to that

>>634611 >just a meme like...Bernd? My dick didn't think it was a meme.

>>634611 >>642765 Its barely a game, it has no business being there.

>>642766 It's no less a game than most VNs and it's actually more of one than many are, including some very popular ones. And Nips tend to be more tolerant of VNs than the western audiences are anyway.

>>642768 Youre saying that as if i consider vns videogames.

>>642773 Well are adventure games videogames? A lot of them are basically VNs with more busy work, from a certain perspective.

So, this will be the games for 2019-2021: 2019 >Katana Zero >Later Alligator >Noita >Risk of Rain 2 >Yuppie Psycho Honorable mention: <Boneworks 2020 >Ghost of Tsushima >Ghostrunner >Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord >Project Wingman >Streets of Rage 4 Honorable mention: <Ultrakill 2021 >Ashes Afterglow (Mod) >Intravenous >It Takes Two >Kaze and the Wild Masks >Necromunda: Hired Gun Honorable mention: <Snoot Game Does that look agreeable to everyone else?

>>642819 Fine by me. A shame about ultrakill, but ghostrunner is the better game.

And, three months later, we finally have the list completed, a list compiling five of the best games, every year, for the past 30 years, from 2021-1992: >/2021/ Ashes Afterglow (Mod) Intravenous It Takes Two Kaze and the Wild Masks Necromunda: Hired Gun >/2020/ Ghost of Tsushima Ghostrunner Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord Project Wingman Streets of Rage 4 >/2019/ Katana Zero Later Alligator Noita Risk of Rain 2 Yuppie Psycho >/2018/ Ion Fury Kingdom Come: Deliverance Overload Spyro Reignited Trilogy World War 3 >/2017/ A Hat in Time Cuphead Hollow Knight Sonic Mania South Park: The Fractured But Whole >/2016/ Factorio Shadow of the Beast Stardew Valley Superhot Titanfall 2 >/2015/ Crypt of the Necrodancer Downwell Fast Racing NEO Hotline Miami 2 Rocket League >/2014/ Alien: Isolation Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor South Park: The Stick of Truth The Talos Principle Wasteland 2 >/2013/ Battleblock Theater Dead Rising 3 Grand Theft Auto V Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon Rayman Legends >/2012/ Darksiders II Dust: An Elysian Tail Hotline Miami Max Payne 3 The Darkness II >/2011/ Dead Rising 2: Off the Record Deus Ex: Human Revolution Mortal Kombat Rayman Origins Serious Sam 3: BFE >/2010/ Bioshock 2 Darksiders Donkey Kong Country Returns Fallout: New Vegas Halo: Reach >/2009/ Batman: Arkham Asylum Halo Wars Left 4 Dead 2 Prototype Punch-Out!! >/2008/ Audiosurf Dead Space Iron Man Spelunky Saints Row 2 >/2007/ Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Crysis Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl The Orange Box >/2006/ Bully Hitman: Blood Money Marvel: Ultimate Alliance Prey Tomb Raider: Legend >/2005/ Battlefield 2 Burnout Revenge F.E.A.R. SWAT 4 Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory >/2004/ Half Life 2 Halo 2 Grand Theft Auto San Andreas Rome: Total War Sid Meier's Pirates >/2003/ Call of Duty Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne Prince of Persia: Sands of Time SSX3 Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic >/2002/ Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Metroid Prime Sly Cooper & The Theivius Raccoonus The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind >/2001/ Burnout Halo Max Payne Serious Sam Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II - Rogue Leader >/2000/ American McGee's Alice Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 Deus Ex Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine Tony Hawk 2 >/1999/ Age of Empires II Rayman 2 Star Wars Episode I Racer Unreal Tournament Worms Armageddon >/1998/ Apocalypse Spyro the Dragon StarCraft I Thief: The Dark Project Turok 2 >/1997/ Blood Crash Bandicoot 2 Fallout Goldeneye 007 Turok: Dinosaur Hunter >/1996/ Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain Civilization II Duke Nukem Quake Tomb Raider >/1995/ Command & Conquer: Tiberian Dawn Donkey Kong Country 2 Full Throttle MechWarrior 2 Twisted Metal >/1994/ Doom II Earthworm Jim Mega Turrican System Shock X-COM: UFO Unknown >/1993/ Cannon Fodder Doom SimCity 2000 Star Fox The Terminator (SEGA CD) >/1992/ Alone in the Dark Flashback Super Star Wars Ultima VII Wolfenstein 3D

>>642839 If you think any of the games listed on the actual list should be disputed, here are the honorable mentions each respective year. Refer to which game you think should be replaced on the actual list with the one from the honorable mentions list. Also, if there is space, we may include one honorable mention for each year: <[2021 Honorable mentions] Snoot Game <[2020 Honorable mentions] Ultrakill <[2019 Honorable mentions] Boneworks <[2018 Honorable mentions] Call of Duty: Black Ops IIII Dusk Hades Return of the Obra Dinn The Messenger Warhammer 40,000: Mechanicus <[2017 Honorable mentions] Alien Shooter TD Battle Brothers Black: The Fall Clone Hero Gun-Running War Dogs Prey Ruiner Spark the Electric Jester The Mummy Demastered Thimbleweed Park <[2016 Honorable Mentions] Blue Revolver Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare Darkest Dungeon Deadbolt Far Cry Primal Mother Russia Bleeds Redout Shantae: 1/2 Genie Hero XCOM <[2015 Honorable mentions] Axoim Verge Call of Duty: Black Ops III Fallout 4 Just Cause 3 Ori and the Blind Forest Pixel Heroes Skyhill <[2014 Honorable mentions] Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Child of Light Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze Freedom Planet Gaunlet Men of War Assault Squad 2 Mercenary Kings Shovel Knight Strider Subnautica Sunset Overdrive The Crew Titanfall Toybox Turbos TxK Watch_Dogs <[2013 Honorable mentions] Bernd and the Mystery of Unteralterbach Batman: Arkham Origins Call of Duty: Ghosts Crysis 3 Don't Starve Guacamelee! Iron Man 3: The Official Game Monaco: What's Yours Is Mine Marlow Briggs and the Mask of Death Outlast Papers, Please Payday 2 Rise of the Triad Risk of Rain Shadow Warrior Shadowrun Returns The Amazing Spider-Man The Bureau: XCOM Declassified The Stanley Parable <[2012 Honorable mentions] Call of Duty: Black Ops II Dishonored Dustforce Far Cry 3 Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams Halo 4 Katawa Shoujo Legend of Grimrock Mark Of The Ninja Need for Speed: Most Wanted SCP: Containment Breach Scribblenauts Unlimited Sine Mora Sleeping Dogs Spec Ops: The Line ZombiU <[2011 Honorable mentions] Alice: Madness Returns Call of Duty: MW3 Dead Island F.3.A.R. Kerbal Space Program Payday: The Heist Terraria Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine <[2010 Honorable mentions] Alpha Protocol Amnesia: The Dark Descent Back to the Future: The Game Call of Duty: Black Ops Castlevania: Lords of Shadow Dead Rising 2 Epic Mickey Limbo Metro 2033 Red Steel 2 Scott Pilgrim vs. The World: The Game Shantae: Risky's Revenge Sid Meier's Civilization V Split/Second Super Meat Boy <[2009 Honorable Mentions] Brutal Legend Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood Cursed Mountain Ghostbusters Killing Floor Minecraft Classic Overlord 2 X-Men Origins: Wolverine - Uncaged Edition Zombie Shooter 2 <[2008 Honorable Mentions] Call of Duty: World At War Castle Crashers Fallout 3 Frontlines: Fuel of War Grand Theft Auto IV Left 4 Dead Nanostray 2 Pure <[2007 Honorable Mentions] BioShock Colin McRae: Dirt Dementium: The Ward Enemy Territory: Quake Wars Mario Strikers Charged Overlord The Witcher Tomb Raider: Anniversary World in Conflict <[2006 Honorable Mentions] Black Dark Messiah of Might and Magic F.E.A.R.: Extraction Point Guitar Hero II Gun Half-Life 2: Episode 1 Medieval II: Total War Slaves to Armok: God of Blood - Chapter II: Dwarf Fortress Titan Quest Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six: Vegas TrackMania Nations <[2005 Honorable Mentions] Batman Begins God of War Need for Speed: Most Wanted Obscure Psychonauts Sid Meier's Civilization IV Super Mario Strikers The Matrix: Path of Neo TimeSitters: Future Perfect Worms 4 Mayhem <[2004 Honorable Mentions] Burnout 3 Takedown Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay Crash Twinsanity Far Cry Manhunt Metroid Prime 2 Need For Speed Underground 2 Painkiller Second Sight Star Wars: Battlefront The Sims 2 The Suffering Unreal Tournament 2004 Van Helsing Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War <[2003 Honorable Mentions] Beyond Good & Evil Jak II Postal 2 Rayman 3 The Simpsons: Hit & Run Tron 2.0 XIII <[2002 Honorable Mentions] Battlefield 1942 BloodRayne Grand Theft Auto Vice City LEGO Island Xtreme Stunts MechAssault Pac-Man World 2 Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Star Wars Jedi Knight 2 Jedi Outcast Tetris Worlds (GC/Xbox) Timesplitters 2 <[2001 Honorable Mentions] Arcanum Conker's Bad Fur Day Empire Earth LEGO Island 2: The Brickster's Revenge GTA3 Gothic IL2 Oni SSX Tricky Zoo Tycoon <[2000 Honorable Mentions] Banjo Tooie Baldur's Gate 2 Metropolis Street Racer Perfect Dark Spider-Man Star Trek: Voyager - Elite Force <[1999 Honorable Mentions] Dungeon Keeper 2 Lego Racers RollerCoaster Tycoon Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Quake III <[1998 Honorable Mentions] Baldur's Gate Fallout 2 Grim Fandango Half-Life Might and Magic VI: The Mandate of Heaven <[1997 Honorable Mentions] Dungeon Keeper Shadow Warrior Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire Tetrisphere <[1996 Honorable Mentions] Crash Bandicoot Descent II Diablo Killer Instinct 2 Master of Orion II: Battle at Antares The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Twisted Metal 2 <[1995 Honorable Mentions] Albion Descent Earthworm Jim 2 I Have No Mouth Phantasmagoria Prehistorik Man Rayman WarCraft II <[1994 Honorable Mentions] Donkey Kong Country Jazz Jackrabbit Killer Instinct NBA Jam The Incredible Machine 2 Uniracers <[1993 Honorable Mentions] Betrayal at Krondor Day of the Tentacle Frontier: Elite II Might and Magic V: Darkside of Xeen Plok Prince of Persia 2 Star Wars: X-Wing The Chaos Engine The Incredible Machine The Lost Vikings <[1992 Honorable Mentions] Darklands King's Quest VI: Heir Today, Gone Tomorrow Might and Magic IV: Clouds of Xeen

>>642819 >Ashes Afterglow (Mod) >Mod is this a joke? >>642839 >It took 3 months to come up with THIS LMAO

>>642840 >all the cowadoody mentions to appease the autist Atleast they arent on the main list.

>>642845 Like was said, the honorable mentions are there if you disagree with something on the may list and want to dispute, and only one honorable mention for each year may be put onto the list if there's space for it.

>>642846 >if there is space for it so, you haven't even thought this thru?

>>642847 The Anon who was helping with making the actually chart while the list was being developed disappeared. What we have close to a PoC is this image: >>616662 And, this soft list with the translated information: >>609146

>>642848 ...so, you haven't done anything for the last 3 months, when you knew you had noone to do the heaving lifting for you, all the while the cod autist was openly saying he was actually working on his, including making his own layout, and was close to finishing his weeks ago? and you were just DONE minutes ago with yours, not even having anything else started or planned as for the actual making of the list as an image for us? well, good luck to you, I think you have a mountain to climb if you want to keep this "list" of yours, I have no horse in this race but I will definitely enjoy the drama that crops up from this!

>>642851 >all the while the cod autist was openly saying he was actually working on his, including making his own layout, and was close to finishing his weeks ago? And, where's his work to show for it? According to him, he was "finished" over a month ago.

>>642873 >And, where's his work to show for it? didn't he post his "completed" list weeks before yours?I'm too lazy to look it up but that's what I was talking about, altho neither of you actually have anything to show for three fucking months this circus has been going on all I am saying is if he actually delivers his receipts, and his completed "official" list contains 17 COD games just to spite you, I ain't gonna have your back, I'm gonna be laughing in the corner, because both of you deserve each other